Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Technical analysis
Technical analysis basics: price, volume and trend
Price position, volume and trend as definitions, what followed on SPY and QQQ since 2000 over a month and a year, and research since Brock et al. (1992).
In one line
Days below the 200-day line, heavy-volume days and months after a negative past year were all followed by bigger moves. Since 2000, SPY's next-day volatility was 29.6% a year below the 200-day line, 2.2 times the 13.2% above it, while the direction of average returns was opposite in the 2000s and after 2010.
Article
Open a chart for the first time and there are so many lines and indicators that it is hard to know where to start. Yet most indicators are price and volume recalculated in different ways, and in the end they ask three things: where the price is now, how much trading is behind the move, and whether there is a direction. Pin those three down first, and you can tell what each other indicator adds.
Technical analysis uses only price and volume. On a chart people mostly look at where price is, how much trading is behind it, and its direction. This article turns those three into definitions that can be calculated, and shows in numbers what followed each state on SPY and QQQ since 2000. Figures are as of September 2026 and were calculated by the operator with the same price data as this site's backtests. Results of rules that buy and sell on moving averages are in Moving-average trading.
The three facts as numbers
- Price position: whether the close is above or below its 200-day simple moving average (the average of the last 200 closes). The distance from the 52-week high carries the same kind of information and is covered in Support, resistance and breakouts.
- Volume: the day's volume divided by the average of the prior 50 trading days. ETF volume changes so much over time that raw volume is hard to compare. SPY's average daily volume in 2008 was more than five times its 2024 level.
- Trend: Dow theory calls it an uptrend when highs and lows both rise. Results depend on how the highs and lows are picked, so this article uses the sign of the past 12-month total return instead. It is the same yardstick Moskowitz, Ooi and Pedersen used in their 2012 study of time-series momentum.
States are judged on split-adjusted closes, and the returns that follow use dividend-reinvested prices. The period runs from January 3, 2000 to September 30, 2026. A month is about 21 trading days and a year about 252.
What research found
In a 1992 paper, Brock, Lakonishok and LeBaron applied 26 moving-average and prior-high and prior-low breakout rules to the Dow Jones Industrial Average from 1897 to 1986. Returns after buy signals were higher than after sell signals, and less volatile. In 1999, Sullivan, Timmermann and White tested 7,846 rules together to correct for data snooping, the error of keeping only the best of many rules. From 1897 to 1986 some rules still beat the benchmark after the correction, but in 1987 to 1996 the probability that even the best rule had not beaten the benchmark was close to 12%, so its value could not be confirmed at the usual standards. In a 2000 paper, LeBaron recalculated a 150-day moving-average rule through 1999. After 1988 the gap in average returns between buy and sell periods had disappeared, but the variance of sell periods stayed at around twice that of buy periods, much as it had for 100 years. Of 95 studies with modern test methods reviewed by Park and Irwin in 2007, 56 found profits, 20 did not, and 19 were mixed, and the authors named data snooping, picking rules after the fact, and estimating risk and costs as common weaknesses.
Above and below the 200-day line (as of September 2026)
Since 2000, closes above the 200-day line made up 72.1% of trading days for SPY and 73.2% for QQQ. The table splits the next day, month and year by that day's position.
| Case | Days | Next-day volatility (annualized) | Average after 21 trading days | Up after 21 trading days | Average after 252 trading days | Up after 252 trading days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SPY, above the 200-day line | 4,846 (72.1%) | 13.2% | 0.90% | 67.6% | 10.9% | 83.6% |
| SPY, below the 200-day line | 1,879 (27.9%) | 29.6% | 0.52% | 56.7% | 7.0% | 62.6% |
| QQQ, above the 200-day line | 4,924 (73.2%) | 19.7% | 1.18% | 65.1% | 13.3% | 84.7% |
| QQQ, below the 200-day line | 1,801 (26.8%) | 40.0% | 0.28% | 55.7% | 10.0% | 64.8% |
What the 200-day line separated most clearly was the size of moves, not their direction. Next-day volatility below the line was more than twice the level above it. Big days also came mostly below the line. Of the 91 days SPY rose more than 3%, 87 followed a close below the 200-day line, and so did 73 of the 94 days it fell more than 3%. For QQQ the counts were 165 of 213 and 180 of 268. Most stretches below the line were short. Of the 94 times SPY fell below its 200-day line, 56 ended within five trading days.
The direction of average returns changed with the period. In 2000 to 2009, the 21 trading days after a close below the line averaged −0.63% for SPY and −1.14% for QQQ, lower than after closes above it. In 2010 to 2026 they averaged 2.31% and 2.69%, higher than above the line (0.98% and 1.40%). SPY spent more than 250 trading days in a row below the line three times in the 2000s, while after 2010 the longest stretch was 162 trading days, from April to November 2022. When declines are short, the month that starts below the line includes the rebound. The volatility gap was similar in both periods. It is the same pattern LeBaron found in a century of Dow data.
Volume: the heaviest days were mostly down days
In a 1987 survey, Karpoff wrote that volume rises with the size of price changes and, in stock markets, with price increases. In 1994, Blume, Easley and O'Hara proposed a model in which volume carries information about the quality of information that price alone does not. In 2001, Gervais, Kaniel and Mingelgrin reported that individual stocks with unusually high volume over a day or a week tended to rise over the following month.
On index ETFs only the size part held. Since 2000, SPY's volume ratio moved with the absolute daily return at a correlation of 0.40, but with the return itself at −0.19. The volume ratio averaged 1.11 on down days and 0.96 on up days, and down days traded more heavily in 26 of 27 calendar years. For QQQ the figures were 1.10 and 0.95, and 25 of 27 years. Volume topped twice the average on 194 days for SPY and 174 for QQQ, and 75% and 77% of those were down days. Volatility over the next 20 trading days was 28.4% for SPY and 32.5% for QQQ, above the overall 15.8% and 21.9%, and the next 63 trading days averaged 4.74% and 5.95%, also above the overall averages (2.35% and 2.71%). Those numbers include the rebounds after sharp drops.
The common belief that a rise on heavy volume is more trustworthy did not show up. After up days with volume at least 1.5 times average, the next 63 trading days averaged 1.73% for SPY (238 days) and 0.97% for QQQ (205 days). After up days on below-average volume they averaged 2.26% (2,380 days) and 2.98% (2,352 days).
Trend: the past year and the next month
At each month end we checked whether the past 12-month total return was positive and measured the next month. For SPY (January 2000 to September 2026, 321 months), the 251 months after a positive year averaged 0.94% with 66.9% of months up, and the 70 months after a negative year averaged 0.10% with 50.0% up. For QQQ (318 months from April 2000), the figures were 1.14% and 59.8% after 254 positive years, and −0.17% and 56.3% after 64 negative ones.
Months with a negative past year made up only 22% of SPY's months, but the big moves clustered in the month after them. Four of the ten best next months (April 2001, April 2009, April 2020 and July 2022) and seven of the ten worst came after a negative year. By period, the 52 months after a negative year in 2000 to 2009 averaged −0.78%, while the 18 in 2010 to 2026 averaged 2.66%. The trend signal worked only in the period when declines lasted. In a 2016 paper, Daniel and Moskowitz reported that the large losses of momentum strategies, which buy recent winners and short recent losers, clustered in sharp rebounds after big market declines. A single index's trend reading was weak in the same stretches.
Related concepts and search terms
- Dow theory: ideas Charles Dow wrote in Wall Street Journal editorials from 1900 to 1902, organized by William Hamilton and by Robert Rhea (The Dow Theory, 1932). In 1998, Brown, Goetzmann and Kumar recalculated that following Hamilton's 1902 to 1929 editorials would have earned positive risk-adjusted returns.
- Weak-form efficiency: the hypothesis that the information in past prices and volume is already in the price. Eugene Fama laid it out in a 1970 paper, and most of the studies above test it.
- Volatility clustering: big moves tend to follow big moves. LeBaron (2000) linked the volatility gap separated by moving-average rules to the leverage effect, volatility rising as prices fall (Black, 1976).
Search terms: technical analysis, 200-day moving average, trading volume, Dow theory, time series momentum, volatility clustering, data snooping, Brock Lakonishok LeBaron.
Limits
- These are results for two US index ETFs over 27 years. Individual stocks, other markets and other periods can differ.
- Counting every day makes the sample look bigger than it is. SPY's 1,879 days below the 200-day line came in 94 stretches, and 2000 to 2002 and 2008 to 2009 account for a large share.
- These are averages by state, not results of trading rules with costs and taxes.
- ETF volume mixes creations, redemptions and hedging trades.
- Splitting the periods at 2010 was a choice made after seeing the results. Other split years give different numbers.
Operator's assessment
In numbers, price position, volume and trend told more consistently how big the next moves would be than which way they would go. Since 2000, SPY's next-day volatility was 29.6% a year below the 200-day line, 2.2 times the 13.2% above it, and the ratio was above 2 in both 2000 to 2009 and 2010 to 2026. The gap in average returns ran in opposite directions in the 2000s, when declines were long, and after 2010, when they were short. Of the days with volume above twice the average, 75% were down days, and heavy volume on up days did not improve what followed. So these three fit the numbers better as a check on whether the market is in a turbulent state than as signals of direction. Confluence Zone checks regime first, as a gate kept out of the score. The numbers above, where the same state led to different results in different periods, show why the two are read separately.
What this article does not cover
This article does not cover any particular stock or trade timing. The figures are averages by state calculated from past daily prices of the US ETFs SPY and QQQ, not results of trading rules with costs and taxes. Indicator values have to be read together with regime and volume, and no conclusion rests on a single value. Everything here is reference information based on past, public data and is not investment advice.
Articles and questions on the same topic
Moving averages and trend following
- Strategy articles: Turtle trading: the 20-day and 55-day breakout rules, tested on ETFs, Dual momentum (GEM): switching between stocks and bonds on 12-month returns
- Backtest questions: Holding TQQQ only while QQQ is above its 200-day line: did it beat buy and hold?, QLD (2x Nasdaq-100) with a 200-day line rule: how different were the drawdown and return from buy and hold?, Buying the golden cross (50-day above 200-day) and selling the death cross: did it beat holding?
- Investor profiles: New-High Growth Momentum Strategy (William O'Neil)
Related
Moving-average trading · Support, resistance and breakouts · Reading indicators · 200-day rule backtest · Livermore's trend breakout · Minervini's trend template
Basics and trading strategies
← VIX, the fear gauge, and crowd psychology · Contents · Support, resistance and breakouts: 52-week highs and pullbacks →
See these metrics on a real stock →
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文