Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › Monthly investing

S&P 500 (SPY): which ended higher, investing monthly or all at once?

The same money put into SPY month by month or all on the first day, compared across many periods since 1993.

Summary

With the same money ($60,000) going into SPY over 10 years from November 2016, putting it all in on the first day ended at $248,609, and spreading it over the months ended at $133,379.

Across 275 ten-year windows since 1993, all at once ended higher in 90% of them. The windows where monthly investing ended higher mostly started in 2000, 1999 and 2001, just before a large decline.

SPY, the same money monthly vs. all on the first day

CasePut inEnd balanceTotal returnAnnual return (IRR)Max drawdownMax loss vs. money in
5 years, monthlyNov 2021 to Oct 2026$30,000$45,995+53.3%17.1%−24.6%−17.4%
5 years, all at onceNov 2021 to Oct 2026$30,000$52,503+75.0%11.9%−24.5%−21.5%
10 years, monthlyNov 2016 to Oct 2026$60,000$133,379+122.3%15.3%−33.7%−13.3%
10 years, all at onceNov 2016 to Oct 2026$60,000$248,609+314.3%15.3%−33.7%−2.2%
15 years, monthlyNov 2011 to Oct 2026$90,000$295,494+228.3%14.5%−33.7%−4.8%
15 years, all at onceNov 2011 to Oct 2026$90,000$721,575+701.8%14.9%−33.7%−4.8%
20 years, monthlyNov 2006 to Oct 2026$120,000$557,340+364.4%13.6%−55.3%−44.8%
20 years, all at onceNov 2006 to Oct 2026$120,000$942,873+685.7%10.9%−55.2%−48.4%

The annual return is based on how long the money was in the market, so its order can differ from the order of end balances.

Comparing 275 ten-year windows

Value
Windows where all at once ended higher248 (90%)
Windows where monthly ended higher27

By window length (every start month)

WindowWindowsAll at once ended higherMedian gap (all at once ÷ monthly − 1)
5 years33580%+29.8%
10 years27590%+52.7%
20 years155100%+77.4%
Share of windows where the lump sum ended aheadInvesting the same money in SPY at once vs. spreading it monthly, by window length. The lump sum ended ahead in 5 years 80%, 10 years 90%, 20 years 100%. Windows counted: 5 years 335, 10 years 275, 20 years 155.0%+20%+40%+60%+80%+100%80%90%100%5 years10 years20 years
Investing the same money in SPY at once vs. spreading it monthly, by window length. The lump sum ended ahead in 5 years 80%, 10 years 90%, 20 years 100%. Windows counted: 5 years 335, 10 years 275, 20 years 155.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

You can change the ticker, period and monthly amount and calculate the same way. No sign-in needed.

Calculate with these settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

Was the loss against the money put in larger when investing all at once?

For the 10 years from Nov 2016 to Oct 2026, the max loss vs. money in was −13.3% for monthly investing and −2.2% for all at once. It varies by window, so neither side was always smaller.

Is this the same as the study that found lump sum ahead about two-thirds of the time?

The comparison differs, so the ratio differs. Vanguard's 2012 study compared investing at once with spreading the same money over 12 months and found the lump sum ahead in about 66% of US 10-year periods from 1926 to 2011; against a 36-month spread it was about 90%. This page compares with spreading the money over the whole 10 years, and money waiting to be invested earns no interest. In this calculation the lump sum was ahead in 90% of windows.

Would the results change with an amount other than $500 a month?

In this SPY calculation, the returns stay almost the same and only the amounts scale. Only the basket method, which buys whole shares, differs a little.

Are dividends included?

Yes. This SPY calculation reinvests each dividend at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.

Would the result be the same when investing in a currency other than dollars?

No. This SPY calculation is in US dollars. Exchange rate changes and the fee and tax differences of locally listed ETFs are not included.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Monthly investing and lump sums

Drawdowns and investor psychology

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文