Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › How to invest and taxes

Investing in a Nasdaq 100 2x ETF through a Korean ISA: how much more was left after tax than QLD in an overseas account?

Korean-listed Nasdaq 100 2x ETFs (TIGER, KODEX) bought monthly in an ISA or a regular account vs. QLD overseas, after tax over 5 and 10 years.

Summary

This calculation is for Korean tax residents. ISAs and pension savings accounts are Korean accounts created under Korean tax law, and the rates and deductions are Korea's, so none of this applies to people living in other countries.

Putting ₩1,666,667 a month (₩100 million in total) into a Nasdaq 100 2x ETF for 5 years left ₩224.6M after tax with the unhedged TIGER ETF in a standard ISA, ₩208.4M with the hedged KODEX ETF in an ISA and ₩192.9M with QLD in an overseas account. The after-tax annual returns were 33.1%, 29.9% and 26.7%.

The gap came from tax and the exchange rate. An ISA taxes gains above the tax-free limit at 9.9%; an overseas account taxes gains above ₩2.5 million a year at 22%. The unhedged TIGER ETF tracks twice the daily Nasdaq 100 return in won, so it takes twice the currency move; the won went from 1,174 to 1,338 per dollar over this period.

Buying the same TIGER ETF in a regular account and selling once at the end turns the gain into dividend income subject to comprehensive taxation. Even with no other income it left ₩206.5M, ₩18.1M less than the ISA and ₩13.6M more than QLD overseas.

With ₩833,333 a month for 10 years, the after-tax balances were ₩617.7M for TIGER in an ISA, ₩401.6M for KODEX in an ISA and ₩440.7M for QLD overseas. Years before the Korean ETFs listed use stand-in prices, so this is less certain than the 5-year result.

5 years of ₩1,666,667 a month, ₩100M in total (2021-11 to 2026-10)

Account and fundBefore taxTaxAfter taxAfter-tax annual return
TIGER, ISA (standard)₩238.1M₩13.5M₩224.6M33.1%
TIGER, ISA (low-income)₩238.1M₩13.3M₩224.8M33.2%
KODEX (hedged), ISA (standard)₩220.1M₩11.7M₩208.4M29.9%
KODEX (hedged), ISA (low-income)₩220.1M₩11.5M₩208.6M30.0%
TIGER, regular account, no other income₩238.1M₩31.6M₩206.5M29.6%
TIGER, regular account, ₩50M other taxable income₩238.1M₩44.6M₩193.6M26.8%
KODEX (hedged), regular account, no other income₩220.1M₩24.6M₩195.5M27.2%
KODEX (hedged), regular account, ₩50M other taxable income₩220.1M₩37.0M₩183.1M24.5%
QLD, overseas account, sold at the end₩218.2M₩25.2M₩192.9M26.7%
QLD, overseas account, ₩2.5M realized each year₩218.1M₩23.5M₩194.5M27.0%

10 years of ₩833,333 a month, ₩100M in total (2016-11 to 2026-10)

Account and fundBefore taxTaxAfter taxAfter-tax annual return
TIGER, ISA (standard)₩674.4M₩56.7M₩617.7M34.2%
TIGER, ISA (low-income)₩674.4M₩56.5M₩617.9M34.2%
KODEX (hedged), ISA (standard)₩434.5M₩32.9M₩401.6M26.2%
KODEX (hedged), ISA (low-income)₩434.5M₩32.7M₩401.7M26.2%
TIGER, regular account, no other income₩674.4M₩219.7M₩454.7M28.5%
TIGER, regular account, ₩50M other taxable income₩674.4M₩235.9M₩438.5M27.9%
KODEX (hedged), regular account, no other income₩434.5M₩112.9M₩321.6M22.1%
KODEX (hedged), regular account, ₩50M other taxable income₩434.5M₩128.0M₩306.4M21.2%
QLD, overseas account, sold at the end₩535.3M₩94.6M₩440.7M28.0%
QLD, overseas account, ₩2.5M realized each year₩534.3M₩89.9M₩444.4M28.1%

Checking the stand-in prices for the Korean 2x ETFs (actual prices with distributions reinvested, since listing)

FundListedActual annual return since listingInvesting error using the stand-in onlyStand-in annual cost before listing
TIGER Nasdaq100 Leverage418660, unhedged2022-02-2232.4%−2.0%3.10% a year
KODEX Nasdaq100 Leverage (H)409820, hedged2021-12-0913.5%−1.6%6.08% a year
QLDUS-listed, same method from 2021-122006-06-2114.9%Not applicable (actual prices)5.59% a year

The calculation uses actual prices after listing and stand-in prices before it. The annual cost is how much the actual price fell short of the daily 2x return each year (for TIGER, the daily 2x return in won); the investing error is the gap had the stand-in alone been used after listing.

Nasdaq 100 2x, ₩100M invested monthly, after-tax balanceAfter-tax balances from the same ₩100 million put in monthly. 5 years: ISA TIGER ₩224.6M, ISA KODEX ₩208.4M, QLD overseas ₩192.9M, Regular TIGER ₩206.5M. 10 years: ISA TIGER ₩617.7M, ISA KODEX ₩401.6M, QLD overseas ₩440.7M, Regular TIGER ₩454.7M. Regular TIGER assumes no other income and a single sale at the end.0₩200M₩400M₩600M₩800M₩225M₩208M₩193M₩207M₩618M₩402M₩441M₩455MISA TIGERISA KODEXQLD overseasRegular TIGER5 years10 years
After-tax balances from the same ₩100 million put in monthly. 5 years: ISA TIGER ₩224.6M, ISA KODEX ₩208.4M, QLD overseas ₩192.9M, Regular TIGER ₩206.5M. 10 years: ISA TIGER ₩617.7M, ISA KODEX ₩401.6M, QLD overseas ₩440.7M, Regular TIGER ₩454.7M. Regular TIGER assumes no other income and a single sale at the end.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

This page is calculated in Korean won. The backtest tool calculates in US dollars, so the numbers will not match. You can see a dollar plan over the same period there.

Calculate with similar settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

How different are the standard and low-income ISAs?

Only the tax-free limit differs (₩2 million vs ₩4 million). Once the gain exceeds ₩4 million, the tax gap is 9.9% of ₩2 million, ₩0.2M, whatever the period or gain. The low-income type requires total pay of ₩50 million or less (or total income of ₩38 million or less) in the previous year; the 3-year holding period and contribution limits are the same.

What if the regular account sells ₩20 million of gains each year?

Realizing up to ₩20 million of gains on the last trading day of each year (14% separate tax) and buying back left the 5-year TIGER case at ₩212.1M after tax, ₩5.5M more than selling once at the end (no other income). When gains grow faster than ₩20 million a year, the rest piles up in the final year and the effect shrinks.

Why was the hedged KODEX lower?

Being hedged, it does not move with the exchange rate, but hedging costs money when US rates are above Korean rates. Fitted to actual prices since listing, the yearly shortfall versus the daily 2x return each fund tracks was 6.08% for KODEX and 3.10% for TIGER, and 5.59% for QLD over the same period. When the won strengthens, TIGER loses twice the currency move.

How reliable is the 10-year result?

The two Korean ETFs listed in December 2021 and February 2022, so earlier years use stand-in prices. The cost is the one fitted after listing, when rates were high; actual costs before 2021, when rates were low, may have been lower. A cost just 1 point a year different changes the 10-year balances by tens of millions of won. The investing error in the check table shows the size of the error left in the 5-year result. Brokerage-type ISAs began in 2021, so the 10-year case assumes the account existed from the start.

Can an ISA hold QLD?

No. An ISA can only hold Korean-listed products, so 2x Nasdaq 100 exposure comes through Korean-listed ETFs such as TIGER or KODEX. Buying leveraged ETFs for the first time requires training and a minimum deposit; check with your broker.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Leveraged ETFs (TQQQ, QLD, SOXL)

Monthly investing and lump sums

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文