Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › Leveraged ETF rules

QLD (2x Nasdaq-100) with a 200-day line rule: how different were the drawdown and return from buy and hold?

QLD while QQQ closes above its 200-day line, cash below it, since listing against buy and hold, plus cash interest, a ±3% band and QLD's own line.

As of the 2026-11-20 close, QQQ is below its 200-day line. See the other lines and indexes

Summary

Holding QLD only while QQQ was above its 200-day line, and cash otherwise, turned $10,000 into $146,813 over the 10 years from November 2016, 30.8% a year. Holding QLD throughout ended at $158,973 (31.9% a year).

The max drawdown over these 10 years was −42.7% for the rule and −63.7% for holding QLD. The rule minus holding came to −21.0 pp in max drawdown size and −1.1 pp in annual return. The rule held QLD on 84% of the days.

Over the full period from July 2006, the month after listing, the max drawdown was −44.1% for the rule and −83.1% for holding QLD, and the annual return was 19.9% and 24.3%.

Shifting a three-year window one month at a time, the rule ended above holding QLD in 32% of windows and had a smaller drawdown in 61%. Of 60 buys over the full period, 41 were sold again within 20 trading days.

This calculation uses the prices of US-listed QLD. It is not a measured result of 2x products listed in other markets.

The rule behind this question: Moving-average trading: the 200-day line, golden cross and 10-month rule

QQQ 200-day rule on QLD vs. buy and hold, $10,000 at the start

CaseEnd balanceTotal returnAnnual returnMax drawdownFillsAvg. stock share
QQQ 200-day rule, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$400,049+3,900.5%19.9%−44.1%12080%
Same rule with cash interest, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$426,212+4,162.1%20.3%−44.0%12080%
±3% band, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$335,887+3,258.9%18.9%−49.7%3278%
QLD's own 200-day line, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$476,612+4,666.1%20.9%−46.4%11474%
Hold QLD, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$831,807+8,218.1%24.3%−83.1%2100%
Hold QQQ, full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026$207,543+1,975.4%16.1%−53.4%2100%
QQQ 200-day rule, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$146,813+1,368.1%30.8%−42.7%3684%
Same rule with cash interest, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$152,924+1,429.2%31.4%−42.7%3684%
±3% band, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$137,029+1,270.3%29.9%−46.0%1283%
QLD's own 200-day line, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$135,438+1,254.4%29.8%−46.4%4681%
Hold QLD, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$158,973+1,489.7%31.9%−63.7%2100%
Hold QQQ, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026$62,953+529.5%20.2%−35.1%2100%
QQQ 200-day rule, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$24,909+149.1%20.1%−36.4%2075%
Same rule with cash interest, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$25,736+157.4%20.8%−34.9%2075%
±3% band, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$21,445+114.4%16.5%−37.1%875%
QLD's own 200-day line, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$23,587+135.9%18.7%−29.4%2672%
Hold QLD, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$19,681+96.8%14.5%−63.7%2100%
Hold QQQ, 5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026$18,349+83.5%12.9%−35.1%2100%

The rule minus holding QLD

PeriodGap in annual returnGap in max drawdown sizeDays holding QLD
Full periodJul 2006 to Oct 2026−4.4 pp−39.1 pp80%
10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 2026−1.1 pp−21.0 pp84%
5 yearsNov 2021 to Oct 2026+5.5 pp−27.3 pp75%

A negative gap in max drawdown size means the rule's largest fall was smaller than holding QLD's.

Signals and cash spells (full period)

QLD
Buys (full period)60
Buys sold again within 20 trading days41
Median holding period3 trading days
Longest cash spell starting in 2008Sold September 2, 2008, bought back May 1, 2009 (167 trading days, QLD −56.0% in between)
Longest cash spell starting in 2018Sold November 12, 2018, bought back February 19, 2019 (65 trading days, QLD −1.3% in between)
Longest cash spell starting in 2020Sold March 12, 2020, bought back April 9, 2020 (20 trading days, QLD +16.3% in between)
Longest cash spell starting in 2022Sold April 6, 2022, bought back January 27, 2023 (203 trading days, QLD −39.6% in between)
Longest cash spell starting in 2025Sold March 7, 2025, bought back May 13, 2025 (46 trading days, QLD +4.9% in between)

The price move in cash spells uses dividend-adjusted QLD prices from the sell to the buy-back.

Every three-year window

200-day rule
Three-year windows209
Share above holding QLD32%
Share above holding QQQ67%
Share with a smaller drawdown than holding QLD61%
Median gap in annual return (rule − hold QLD)−12.1 pp

Calendar-year returns

YearRuleHold QLDHold QQQ
2007+29.0%+29.0%+19.0%
2008−21.4%−72.9%−41.7%
2009+63.2%+121.2%+54.7%
2010+2.5%+36.9%+20.1%
2011−22.8%+0.0%+3.5%
2012+5.9%+34.8%+18.1%
2013+70.8%+82.1%+36.6%
2014+37.3%+37.6%+19.2%
2015−14.2%+14.7%+9.4%
2016−6.1%+10.0%+7.1%
2017+70.3%+70.3%+32.7%
2018+4.9%−8.3%−0.1%
2019+30.2%+81.7%+39.0%
2020+64.7%+88.9%+48.6%
2021+54.7%+54.7%+27.4%
2022−28.2%−60.5%−32.6%
2023+67.5%+117.7%+54.9%
2024+42.8%+42.8%+25.6%
2025+23.9%+30.4%+20.8%
2026 (to Oct)+11.6%+17.3%+12.6%

The first year of the full period is left out because it started mid-year.

One year after buying QLD with QQQ above or below the 200-day line (buys from 2006-06 to 2025-10)

QQQ that dayShare of daysQLD 1 year later, medianQLD chance of a loss after 1 yearQLD next month's volatility (annual)QQQ 1 year later, medianQQQ chance of a loss after 1 year
Above the 200-day line79.2%+33.8%18.4%29.6%+19.2%12.3%
Below the 200-day line20.8%+49.4%21.4%51.6%+26.9%19.8%

The one-year windows overlap day by day, so the truly independent cases are a handful of large downturns.

QLD, $10,000 at the start: QQQ 200-day rule vs. buy and hold (month-end, log scale)Month-end balance of $10,000 under the rule, holding QLD and holding QQQ, Jul 2006 to Oct 2026. In the last month the rule was at $400,049, holding QLD at $831,807 and holding QQQ at $207,543.$5k$10k$25k$50k$100k$250k$500k$1MHold QLD200-day ruleHold QQQ2008201020122014201620182020202220242026
Month-end balance of $10,000 under the rule, holding QLD and holding QQQ, Jul 2006 to Oct 2026. In the last month the rule was at $400,049, holding QLD at $831,807 and holding QQQ at $207,543.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

The moving-average signal model in the backtest tool (signal ticker QQQ, 200 days) reruns the same rule with the same calculation. You can change the signal ticker, the number of days and the band there.

Calculate with these settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

What if QLD's own 200-day line is used instead?

Over the last 10 years, the rule on QLD's own 200-day line returned 29.8% a year (max drawdown −46.4%), against 30.8% (−42.7%) with the QQQ signal.

Doesn't it flip back and forth around the 200-day line?

It does. Of 60 buys over the full period, 41 were sold again within 20 trading days. Buying 3% above the line and selling 3% below it cut the last 10 years' fills from 36 to 12, with an annual return of 29.9%.

Would interest on cash change the result?

Over the last 10 years the rule was in cash 16% of the days, and the 3-month Treasury bill averaged 2.5% a year. With that interest on cash it ended at $152,924, 31.4% a year.

What happened in 2008?

The return for calendar 2008 was −72.9% for holding QLD, −21.4% for the rule and −41.7% for holding QQQ.

How is it different from the TQQQ 200-day rule?

The signal is the same: buy when QQQ closes above its 200-day line and sell when it closes below. That question trades TQQQ, a 3× ETF, and this question trades QLD, a 2× ETF.

How is it different from the QQQ 200-day monthly rule?

The 200-day monthly question adds $500 a month to QQQ and pauses below the 200-day line. This question puts in $10,000 once and uses QQQ's 200-day line to buy and sell QLD, a 2× ETF.

How different was buying with QQQ below the 200-day line from buying above it?

Buying QLD on days QQQ was below the 200-day line had a median one-year return of +49.4%, and +33.8% on days above it. The chance of a loss after a year was 21.4% below and 18.4% above, and next month's volatility was 51.6% and 29.6% a year.

Are dividends included?

Yes. This QLD 200-day rule calculation reinvests each dividend at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.

Would the result be the same when investing in a currency other than dollars?

No. This QLD 200-day rule calculation is in US dollars. Exchange rate changes and the fee and tax differences of locally listed ETFs are not included.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Leveraged ETFs (TQQQ, QLD, SOXL)

Moving averages and trend following

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文