Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › How to invest and taxes

Stopping or continuing monthly investing during a crash: how different were the results?

$500 a month into SPY and QQQ, stopped in months 20% or more below the high vs. never stopped, with the 2000, 2008, 2020 and 2022 falls shown separately.

Summary

$500 a month into SPY from January 1994 to October 2026 added up to $197,000 put in. Kept investing ended at $1,615,449, an annual return (IRR) of 10.7%, with a max drawdown of −55.2%. SPY was 20% or more below its high in 85 of those months. Stopping in those months and keeping the money in cash ended at $1,223,479, 9.4% a year, max drawdown −45.4%. Stopping and putting the saved cash in all at once on resuming ended at $1,535,350, 10.5% a year, max drawdown −54.8%.

$500 a month into QQQ from April 1999 to October 2026 added up to $165,500 put in. Kept investing ended at $1,921,946, an annual return (IRR) of 14.8%, with a max drawdown of −83.0%. QQQ was 20% or more below its high in 182 of those months. Stopping in those months and keeping the money in cash ended at $423,421, 6.2% a year, max drawdown −61.2%. Stopping and putting the saved cash in all at once on resuming ended at $1,019,135, 11.3% a year, max drawdown −66.9%. QQQ stayed stopped for 166 months in a row, from October 2000 to July 2014.

Each fall runs from the month of the high to the month the high was regained. Stopped months were 52 in the 2000 fall, 30 in the 2008 fall, 1 in the 2020 fall and 2 in the 2022 fall for SPY, and 169 in the 2000 fall, 40 in the 2008 fall, 0 in the 2020 fall and 13 in the 2022 fall for QQQ.

The longest period and since January 2000, $500 a month

CasePut inPut in the ETFEnd balanceAnnual return (IRR)Max drawdownStopped months
SPY, kept investingJan 1994 to Oct 2026$197,000$197,000$1,615,44910.7%−55.2%0
SPY, stopped, money kept in cashJan 1994 to Oct 2026$197,000$154,500$1,223,4799.4%−45.4%85
SPY, stopped, all in on resumingJan 1994 to Oct 2026$197,000$197,000$1,535,35010.5%−54.8%85
QQQ, kept investingApr 1999 to Oct 2026$165,500$165,500$1,921,94614.8%−83.0%0
QQQ, stopped, money kept in cashApr 1999 to Oct 2026$165,500$74,500$423,4216.2%−61.2%182
QQQ, stopped, all in on resumingApr 1999 to Oct 2026$165,500$165,500$1,019,13511.3%−66.9%182
SPY, kept investingJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$161,000$968,06611.5%−55.2%0
SPY, stopped, money kept in cashJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$118,500$576,0968.4%−40.8%85
SPY, stopped, all in on resumingJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$161,000$887,96811.0%−55.0%85
QQQ, kept investingJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$161,000$1,859,07015.2%−83.0%0
QQQ, stopped, money kept in cashJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$70,000$360,5455.5%−46.5%182
QQQ, stopped, all in on resumingJan 2000 to Oct 2026$161,000$161,000$956,25911.4%−59.2%182

The upper rows start in the first full month of the price data, and the lower rows start on the same date for both ETFs.

SPY by fall, from the month of the high to the month it was regained

CasePut inPut in the ETFEnd balanceAnnual return (IRR)Max drawdownStopped months
2000 fall, kept investingMar 2000 to Jun 2007$44,000$44,000$60,5538.6%−47.8%0
2000 fall, stopped, money kept in cashMar 2000 to Jun 2007$44,000$18,000$47,1141.9%−35.5%52
2000 fall, stopped, all in on resumingMar 2000 to Jun 2007$44,000$44,000$53,7895.4%−36.7%52
2008 fall, kept investingOct 2007 to Mar 2013$33,000$33,000$46,27012.3%−55.4%0
2008 fall, stopped, money kept in cashOct 2007 to Mar 2013$33,000$18,000$36,6943.8%−48.5%30
2008 fall, stopped, all in on resumingOct 2007 to Mar 2013$33,000$33,000$41,0897.9%−48.5%30
2020 fall, kept investingFeb 2020 to Aug 2020$3,500$3,500$4,121Under 1 year−33.8%0
2020 fall, stopped, money kept in cashFeb 2020 to Aug 2020$3,500$3,000$3,916Under 1 year−33.8%1
2020 fall, stopped, all in on resumingFeb 2020 to Aug 2020$3,500$3,500$4,029Under 1 year−33.8%1
2022 fall, kept investingJan 2022 to Jan 2024$12,500$12,500$14,59915.1%−24.7%0
2022 fall, stopped, money kept in cashJan 2022 to Jan 2024$12,500$11,500$14,26412.7%−24.3%2
2022 fall, stopped, all in on resumingJan 2022 to Jan 2024$12,500$12,500$14,49614.3%−25.6%2

QQQ by fall, from the month of the high to the month it was regained

CasePut inPut in the ETFEnd balanceAnnual return (IRR)Max drawdownStopped months
2000 fall, kept investingMar 2000 to Sep 2016$99,500$99,500$269,75111.1%−83.1%0
2000 fall, stopped, money kept in cashMar 2000 to Sep 2016$99,500$15,000$101,7140.3%−42.0%169
2000 fall, stopped, all in on resumingMar 2000 to Sep 2016$99,500$99,500$125,2852.7%−57.5%169
2008 fall, kept investingOct 2007 to Jan 2011$20,000$20,000$27,16418.7%−53.6%0
2008 fall, stopped, money kept in cashOct 2007 to Jan 2011$20,000$0$20,0000.0%0.0%40
2008 fall, stopped, all in on resumingOct 2007 to Jan 2011$20,000$0$20,0000.0%0.0%40
2020 fall, kept investingFeb 2020 to Jun 2020$2,500$2,500$2,934Under 1 year−28.6%0
2020 fall, stopped, money kept in cashFeb 2020 to Jun 2020$2,500$2,500$2,934Under 1 year−28.6%0
2020 fall, stopped, all in on resumingFeb 2020 to Jun 2020$2,500$2,500$2,934Under 1 year−28.6%0
2022 fall, kept investingNov 2021 to Dec 2023$13,000$13,000$16,27821.5%−35.3%0
2022 fall, stopped, money kept in cashNov 2021 to Dec 2023$13,000$6,500$13,7124.8%−29.9%13
2022 fall, stopped, all in on resumingNov 2021 to Dec 2023$13,000$13,000$14,88512.6%−29.9%13

End balances for the same falls up to the lowest close only

CasePrice vs. that highPut inKept investingStopped, cashStopped, all in
SPY, 2000 fallMar 2000 to Oct 2002−49.1%$16,000$10,615$12,836$12,653
SPY, 2008 fallOct 2007 to Mar 2009−56.5%$9,000$5,309$6,008$6,008
SPY, 2020 fallFeb 2020 to Mar 2020−34.1%$1,000$721$721$721
SPY, 2022 fallJan 2022 to Oct 2022−25.4%$5,000$4,309$4,342$4,279
QQQ, 2000 fallMar 2000 to Oct 2002−83.0%$16,000$7,416$14,388$13,179
QQQ, 2008 fallOct 2007 to Nov 2008−53.6%$7,000$3,926$7,000$7,000
QQQ, 2020 fallFeb 2020 to Mar 2020−28.6%$1,000$787$787$787
QQQ, 2022 fallNov 2021 to Dec 2022−35.6%$7,000$5,635$6,090$6,090

Calculated from the first month to the day of the lowest close after that high.

Stopped months and resumptions in the longest period

StoppedMonthsMoney savedResumedPrice in between
SPY, Apr 20011$500May 2001+7.5%
SPY, Jul 2001 to Jul 200549$24,500Aug 2005+7.7%
SPY, Sep 20051$500Oct 2005+0.8%
SPY, Nov 20051$500Dec 2005+4.5%
SPY, Oct 2008 to Dec 201027$13,500Jan 2011+15.6%
SPY, Sep 2011 to Oct 20112$1,000Nov 2011+0.3%
SPY, Dec 20111$500Jan 2012+3.0%
SPY, Apr 20201$500May 2020+15.1%
SPY, Jul 20221$500Aug 2022+8.7%
SPY, Oct 20221$500Nov 2022+8.0%
QQQ, Jun 2000 to Aug 20003$1,500Sep 2000+20.9%
QQQ, Oct 2000 to Jul 2014166$83,000Aug 2014+13.8%
QQQ, May 2022 to May 202313$6,500Jun 2023+12.0%

The price in between is the dividend-adjusted move from the open on the first stopped day to the open on the day of resuming.

SPY, $500 a month: kept investing vs. stopped (month-end balance, log scale)Month-end balance of $500 a month into SPY in three cases, Jan 1994 to Oct 2026. Gray bands mark the stopped months, and the dotted line is the money put in. In the last month kept investing was at $1,615,449, stopped with cash at $1,223,479 and stopped then all in at $1,535,350, with $197,000 put in.$1k$2.5k$5k$10k$25k$50k$100k$250k$500k$1MKeptStopped, all inStopped, cashMoney in19962000200420082012201620202024
Month-end balance of $500 a month into SPY in three cases, Jan 1994 to Oct 2026. Gray bands mark the stopped months, and the dotted line is the money put in. In the last month kept investing was at $1,615,449, stopped with cash at $1,223,479 and stopped then all in at $1,535,350, with $197,000 put in.
QQQ, $500 a month: kept investing vs. stopped (month-end balance, log scale)Month-end balance of $500 a month into QQQ in three cases, Apr 1999 to Oct 2026. Gray bands mark the stopped months, and the dotted line is the money put in. In the last month kept investing was at $1,921,946, stopped with cash at $423,421 and stopped then all in at $1,019,135, with $165,500 put in.$1k$2.5k$5k$10k$25k$50k$100k$250k$500k$1MKeptStopped, all inStopped, cashMoney in2000200420082012201620202024
Month-end balance of $500 a month into QQQ in three cases, Apr 1999 to Oct 2026. Gray bands mark the stopped months, and the dotted line is the money put in. In the last month kept investing was at $1,921,946, stopped with cash at $423,421 and stopped then all in at $1,019,135, with $165,500 put in.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

The stop rule is not in the backtest tool yet. The kept-investing row for QQQ from January 2000 can be calculated there with the same dates.

Calculate with these settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

How were the stopped months decided?

The close on the trading day before each deposit is compared with the highest close up to then. If it was 20% or more below, no ETF was bought that month. Prices are split-adjusted closes, as on a chart, and the high goes back to the first day of the price data. Buying resumed on the next deposit day that was not 20% or more below. Only one day a month is checked, so a drop that recovers within a month is not caught. In the 2020 fall the lowest close was −34.1% from the high for SPY and −28.6% for QQQ. The number of stopped months was 1 for SPY and 0 for QQQ.

Does the money from stopped months count as money put in?

Yes. All three cases treat $500 as leaving on the same day every month when calculating the annual return (IRR). So the money put in is the same, and only the money put in the ETF differs. Counting only the money put in the ETF and its balance, the longest period's annual return for keeping the stopped money in cash changes from 9.4% to 10.5% for SPY and from 6.2% to 12.4% for QQQ.

Why does QQQ's 2008 period have no money in the ETF?

Because the high goes back to QQQ's listing. In the first month of this period QQQ was already 56.3% below its March 2000 high, and it was still 20% or more below on every deposit day until the period ended. Measuring the high from the first month of this period instead gives 20 stopped months and $10,000 put in the ETF, with end balances of $21,591 for keeping the money in cash, $23,712 for all in on resuming and $27,164 for kept investing.

How were the start and end of each period chosen?

Each fall starts with the first deposit in the month of the high and ends in the month the high was regained, with nothing built up before it. Ending when the high is regained means the balance is measured after the shares bought at low prices have recovered. End balances at the lowest close are in a separate table. Where the period ends changes the gaps between the three cases.

What was the longest stop?

For QQQ, 166 months from October 2000 to July 2014. For SPY, 49 months from July 2001 to July 2005. The money saved in that time was $83,000 for QQQ and $24,500 for SPY. From the open on the first stopped day to the open on the day of resuming, the dividend-adjusted price moved +13.8% for QQQ and +7.7% for SPY.

Would interest on the cash change the result?

The cash in the tables earns no interest. With the 3-month Treasury bill rate on it, the longest period's end balance for keeping the stopped money in cash was $1,241,137 for SPY and $457,363 for QQQ, and for all in on resuming it was $1,543,539 for SPY and $1,071,640 for QQQ.

How is it different from doubling on drops?

The −20% trigger is the same. The doubling question puts in $1,000 that month, and this question buys no ETF that month.

Are dividends included?

Yes. This SPY and QQQ stopped-investing calculation reinvests each dividend at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.

Would the result be the same when investing in a currency other than dollars?

No. This SPY and QQQ stopped-investing calculation is in US dollars. Exchange rate changes and the fee and tax differences of locally listed ETFs are not included.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Monthly investing and lump sums

Drawdowns and investor psychology

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文