Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy

Contrarian · Bargain

Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy

John Templeton · John Templeton · 1912–2008 · United States → United Kingdom
Buys when everyone gives up, but only companies that will survive

What is the Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy?

The Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy buys at the point of greatest pessimism and sells as optimism spreads. The key is picking, among stocks everyone has abandoned after a big fall, the companies whose finances can hold up. It turns John Templeton's principles into rules.

Who He Was

Born in 1912 in Tennessee. He studied economics at Yale and, as a Rhodes Scholar, law at Oxford.

In 1939, as World War II began and everyone was selling, he borrowed money to buy $100 of each of the 104 stocks trading below $1 on the New York exchanges. Thirty-four of them by the count of the Templeton Foundation, or 37 in another biography, were already in bankruptcy, yet four years later the investment was worth about four times what he paid.

He founded the Templeton Growth Fund in 1954, and the fund began to beat the market consistently in the 1970s. He invested early in Japanese stocks when few others did, and in the 1970s the fund at one point held as much as 60% of its assets in Japan. He sold his fund company to Franklin in 1992, and profited by shorting technology stocks in the 2000 dot-com bubble.

He gave up his US citizenship, moved to the Bahamas and became a British citizen, and was knighted in 1987. The same year he set up the John Templeton Foundation and gave away much of his wealth. He died in the Bahamas in 2008.

Core Idea

His principle was that the moment of greatest pessimism is the best time to buy. If everyone has already sold, nobody is left to sell, and the worst case is already in the price. Then even less-bad news lifts it.

What he bought was not pessimism itself, but prices that had fallen below value because people sold.

The contrarian buy zone is where despair is fully reflected in the price.Euphoria - time to sellMax pessimism - time to buyEmotion cycle: optimism → euphoria → anxiety → fear → despair → recovery
The contrarian buy zone is where despair is fully reflected in the price.

Trading Rules

1. Look where prices have fallen most

Look at stocks, markets and countries that have fallen far from their highs. Unlike trend following, the score here rises the further the price has fallen.

2. Buy only companies that will survive

Even in 1939, spreading the money across every listed company was the safety net. For individual stocks he always checked profits and whether the debt was manageable. A low price only matters if the company survives.

3. Wait for the decline to stop

No longer making new lows is one sign that pessimism is ending. If the stock is still setting new lows, there is no hurry.

4. Search the whole world

Pessimism reaches different countries at different times. Watching one market misses most of the chances.

5. Sell when everyone is optimistic

Contrarian thinking applies to selling as much as to buying.

The Record

The main source for the 1939 investment is Templeton's own recollection. As recalled in Jonathan Davis and Alasdair Nairn's Templeton's Way with Money (2012), when the war began he asked his broker to buy $100 of every stock on the New York Stock Exchange trading at $1 or less, and within four years he had four times his money. The money was a $10,000 loan from his former boss. He bought 104 stocks; the number already in bankruptcy is 34 according to the John Templeton Foundation and 37 according to the book. The same book notes that on September 1, 1943, four years later, the Dow Jones Industrial Average was less than 2% above its level on the day he bought. No account records have been published (not verified).

The fund record is in its reports. According to the fund's 1996 annual report, as cited in the same book, $10,000 invested in the Templeton Growth Fund on November 29, 1954 grew to $2,848,809 by August 31, 1996 with dividends and distributions reinvested. This site calculates that as about 14.5% a year. The John Templeton Foundation states that the amount was about $2 million in 1992, when he sold the business to Franklin.

The fund did not beat the market from the start. Davis and Nairn estimated that in its first 10 years it would have struggled to keep up with the MSCI World Index, which did not yet exist, and wrote that it began to outperform consistently only in the 1970s. Its net asset value fell 9.9% in 1973 and 12.1% in 1974, less than the main market index. At one point it had as much as 60% of its assets in Japanese stocks. When the business was sold to Franklin Resources in 1992, it managed $21.3 billion.

The numbers for his 2000 short sales come from a Forbes article of May 28, 2001. He shorted 84 Nasdaq stocks, averaging $2.2 million per position, timing each one 11 days before the end of the lockup period that kept existing shareholders from selling after the IPO. By the time of the article his gains were $86 million.

What Research Found

The best-known study of whether beaten-down stocks recover is De Bondt and Thaler (1985). In US stocks from 1926 to 1982, the 35 stocks that had trailed the market most over the past 3 years beat the market by 19.6% over the next 36 months, while the 35 that had led the most trailed it by 5.0%, a gap of 24.6%. Most of the excess return came in January, and more of it came in the second and third years than in the first.

There are counterarguments. Losers include many small companies, so the gap may reflect company size or risk. Chopra, Lakonishok and Ritter (1992) reported that after adjusting for size and beta, the biggest losers of the past 5 years still beat the biggest winners by 5 to 10% a year over the next 5 years, but the effect was much stronger among small companies. Fama and French (1996) found that several patterns, including long-term reversals, are largely explained by a three-factor model of market, size and value, and read them as compensation for risk.

Some research looks at whole countries, as Templeton did. Richards (1997) found reversals in the stock indexes of 16 countries, with markets that had fallen the most later beating those that had risen the most. He reported no evidence that the loser countries were riskier in terms of volatility, co-movement with the world market or performance in bad economic times.

Asness, Moskowitz and Pedersen (2013) reported that value and momentum strategies both earned excess returns across eight markets and asset classes, but their returns tended to move in opposite directions. The same difference is why this site's Templeton score and trend-following scores rate the same stock in opposite ways.

In short, the finding that beaten-down stocks and markets did better on average afterward has been repeated in many studies, but there is no agreement on whether the reason is investor overreaction or compensation for risk. The reversals played out over several years.

This Site's Price-Rule Backtest

The Templeton model in this site's backtest tool uses only price. When the close is at or below 70% of the previous 52-week high (a drop of 30% or more), the 14-day RSI has just moved from 35 or below to above 35, and that day's low is above the lowest low of the previous 60 days, it buys with all its cash at the next day's open. When the close recovers to 90% or more of the 52-week high, or the RSI reaches 70 or higher, it sells everything at the next day's open. P/B, profitability and the debt ratio are left out.

The period is the longest the tool allows, 20 years from October 2, 2006 to September 30, 2026, applied to QQQ and SPY separately. The only money is $10,000 invested once, and each trade costs 0.15%. Signals use prices adjusted only for splits, while fills and valuation use prices with dividends reinvested. Cash earns no interest.

PortfolioAnnual returnMax drawdownFillsTime in stocksFinal value
QQQ Templeton model0.4%−29.4%45.9%$10,744
QQQ buy and hold16.5%−53.4%2100%$212,867
SPY Templeton model−0.3%−34.5%23.9%$9,451
SPY buy and hold11.1%−55.2%2100%$82,070

Time in stocks is the share of trading days on which the portfolio held shares. Over 20 years the model traded twice in QQQ and once in SPY, and all three sales came when the RSI reached 70. In QQQ it bought at the open on October 14, 2008; the close on November 20 was 29.3% below the purchase price, and it sold on May 5, 2009 at −2.9%. From the day it sold to the end of 2009, QQQ rose another 31.1%. It bought again on June 16, 2022 and sold on February 3, 2023 with an 11.3% gain, after which QQQ rose 146.8% through September 2026. In SPY it bought on October 14, 2008; the close on March 9, 2009 was 34.4% below the purchase price, and it sold on July 24, 2009 at −5.2%.

There was no signal in 2020. QQQ's lowest close was 71.3% of its 52-week high, short of a 30% drop. SPY was below 70% on only two days, March 20 and 23, when its RSI was below 35; on March 24, when the RSI rose above 35, SPY's close was already back at 71.7% of its 52-week high.

Templeton picked individual companies around the world after checking their finances, while this calculation applies only price conditions to two US index ETFs. Indexes rarely fall more than 30%, so the model traded only three times in 20 years. The app's Templeton panel score uses P/B, profitability and the debt ratio, and it is not backtested because historical point-in-time financials are not available. The table shows the simplified price rule of the backtest tool, not the panel score.

Cautions

A falling knife is not a bottomA big drop is not enough on its own. A company whose finances have collapsed keeps falling and can go to zero. The financial check and the end of new lows are both needed.
It can take yearsPessimism lasts longer than expected. You often buy too early and sit on losses for a while, which is hard with borrowed money or a short horizon.
Do not mix it with trend followingThis strategy and trend following give the same stock opposite scores. That is why this site shows where strategies disagree, and why you need to choose your own approach first.

How This App Scores It

This strategy card checks the following.
  • Down 30% or more from the 52-week high (more points for bigger drops), RSI oversold
  • P/B of 1.5x or below
  • Profitable in the last 4 quarters, debt ratio of 200% or below
  • Whether 60-bar new lows have stopped, and whether the index is also in a fearful regime

Primary Sources

  • Lauren Templeton & Scott Phillips, Investing the Templeton Way (2008)

This strategy model was independently built by Confluence Zone to quantify the investment philosophy in the works above. It is not an official model created, endorsed or reviewed by John Templeton or any related institution. Last reviewed: 2026-10-02

Related terms: PER · PBR · Dividend Yield

See the Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy score in the app →

Articles and questions on the same topic

Drawdowns and investor psychology

Other strategies

← Explore Investing Strategies

These explainers are educational summaries, independently written from publicly available books, records and interviews. No person or institution named here is evaluating or recommending any security. Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文