Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers

Questions and answers

Common investing questions, answered with numbers calculated from actual prices.

Backtest questions

Calculated from actual daily prices of US ETFs (QQQ, SPY, QLD, TQQQ, SOXL, SOXX, UPRO, TMF, SCHD, QYLD, JEPQ, IEF). Monthly investing questions put in $500 a month; system trading questions put in $10,000 once at the start. Every question charges 0.15% on each buy or sell, and dividends are reinvested except on the one question that compares spending them.

Monthly investing

QuestionResult in brief
What would investing in QQQ (Nasdaq-100) every month have returned?10-year monthly investing returned 19.3% a year; −5.4% to 24.1% depending on the start
S&P 500 (SPY): which ended higher, investing monthly or all at once?All at once ended higher in 90% of 275 ten-year windows
QQQ vs. SPY: how different were the results of investing monthly over the same period?QQQ ended higher in all 212 ten-year windows

How to invest and taxes

QuestionResult in brief
Investing in US ETFs every month in Korean won: how different was the return from the dollar return?QQQ, 10 years of ₩500,000 a month: 21.5% a year in won, 19.3% in dollars
Investing daily, weekly or monthly: which ended higher?QQQ over 10 years: daily 19.2% a year, monthly 19.3%, a gap of 0.16 pp at most
Investing in US ETFs from Korea: how much did taxes differ between an overseas account, an ISA and pension savings?QQQ, 10 years of ₩500,000 a month: tax ₩26.2M overseas, ₩11.9M in an ISA, ₩10.2M in pension savings
Investing in a Nasdaq 100 2x ETF through a Korean ISA: how much more was left after tax than QLD in an overseas account?Nasdaq 100 2x, 5 years of monthly investing: ₩224.6M after tax with TIGER in an ISA, ₩192.9M with QLD overseas
Doubling monthly contributions when the market is 20% below its high: did it beat the same amount every month?QQQ over 10 years: doubling at −20% returned 19.6% a year vs. 19.3% for the same amount every month
Stopping or continuing monthly investing during a crash: how different were the results?SPY from Jan 1994: kept investing 10.7% a year, stopped with cash 9.4%, stopped then all in 10.5%

Leveraged ETF investing

QuestionResult in brief
How did investing in TQQQ every month compare with QQQ and QLD?15-year monthly investing, annual return: TQQQ 38.2%, QLD 30.7%, QQQ 19.1%
Does TQQQ decay if you hold it long? How far was it from three times QQQ?TQQQ vs. three times QQQ over 12 months: +10.2 pp when QQQ rose steadily, −14.1 pp when it ended flat (medians)
SOXL (3x semiconductors) monthly investing: how did it compare with SOXX and TQQQ?15-year monthly investing, annual return: SOXL 41.0%, SOXX 28.1%, TQQQ 38.2%
QLD (2x Nasdaq-100): which ended higher, investing monthly or all at once?QLD: all at once ended higher in 97% of 125 ten-year windows
Leveraged ETF monthly investing: how much does the start date matter?TQQQ 5-year monthly investing: −8.1% to 76.2% a year (141 runs)

Leveraged ETF rules

QuestionResult in brief
TQQQ basket method: what do the backtest results show?240 slots at $500 each: $39,866 put in, $2,435,523 at the end
TQQQ, QLD and QQQ cross-rebalancing: how does it compare with simply holding?15 years: 27.0% a year, max drawdown −55.0%
TQQQ infinite buying method: did it beat buy and hold in a backtest?TQQQ over 10 years: infinite buying 20.7% a year, buy and hold 38.2%
TQQQ value rebalancing (VR): did it beat buy and hold or regular investing in a backtest?TQQQ over 10 years: value rebalancing 37.6% a year, buy and hold 38.2%
Holding TQQQ only while QQQ is above its 200-day line: did it beat buy and hold?TQQQ over 10 years: QQQ 200-day rule 42.1% a year, buy and hold 38.2%
QLD (2x Nasdaq-100) with a 200-day line rule: how different were the drawdown and return from buy and hold?QLD over 10 years: QQQ 200-day rule 30.8% a year, max drawdown −42.7%; buy and hold 31.9%, −63.7%
HFEA (55% UPRO, 45% TMF, rebalanced quarterly): did it still beat SPY after 2022?HFEA (UPRO 55%, TMF 45%) since Jul 2009: 23.1% a year, −63.8% in 2022, max drawdown −70.6%

Moving average touches

Rules

QuestionResult in brief
Does selling below the 200-day moving average reduce drawdowns in monthly investing?QQQ 20 years: max drawdown −53.5% vs. −25.1%; plain monthly investing ended higher in all 6 cases
How much less does a 70% stock, 30% cash mix fall than 100% stocks?SPY 20 years, 70/30: max drawdown −55.3% vs. −42.4%

System trading

QuestionResult in brief
Grid trading on QQQ and TQQQ: did it beat simply holding?QQQ over 10 years: grid 2.7% a year, buy and hold 20.2%
Grid trading with lines 3%, 5% or 10% apart: which spacing did best?QQQ full period, annual return: 1.9% at 3% spacing, 2.2% at 5%, 2.5% at 10%
Larry Williams volatility breakout on QQQ: did it beat simply holding?QQQ k 0.5: −17.3% a year at 0.15% cost, 13.3% at no cost, buy and hold 8.3%
Buying the golden cross (50-day above 200-day) and selling the death cross: did it beat holding?QQQ since 2000: golden cross 10.9% a year, buy and hold 8.3%
Turtle trading breakout rules (20-day, 55-day): do they still work on ETFs?QQQ since 2000: Turtle System 2 2.5% a year, buy and hold 8.3%

Dividends and income

QuestionResult in brief
SCHD (dividend growth ETF) vs. SPY and QQQ: how did monthly investing compare?10-year monthly investing: SCHD 13.9%, SPY 15.3%, QQQ 19.3% a year
Covered call ETFs (QYLD, JEPQ) pay large distributions. Did they beat QQQ?Since Jan 2014: QYLD 8.6% a year vs. QQQ 18.4%, distributions reinvested
How much more do reinvested dividends add than spending them?SPY over 20 years: reinvested $557,340 vs. spent $485,048 (balance plus dividends)

Common questions

What changed monthly investing results the most?

The start date. Even the same 10-year QQQ plan returned anywhere from −5.4% to 24.1% a year depending on when it started.

Can these results tell me which ETF to buy?

No. They are calculations of rules on past prices. They do not recommend any product or timing.

Try it yourself

Enter a ticker and conditions to calculate the same way.

Open the backtest

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文