Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › Rules
Does selling below the 200-day moving average reduce drawdowns in monthly investing?
Monthly investing in QQQ and SPY with a rule to hold cash below the 200-day line, vs. plain monthly investing, with and without T-bill interest.
As of the 2026-11-20 close, QQQ is below its 200-day line. See the other lines and indexes
Summary
The drawdown got smaller. Putting money into QQQ every month for 20 years from November 2006 had a max drawdown of −53.5%. With a rule of selling below the 200-day moving average and buying back above it, it was −25.1%.
In exchange, the end balance was $542,540, less than plain monthly investing ($983,465), and there were 115 trades over 20 years. In none of the 6 cases calculated did the rule end higher.
With 3-month Treasury bill interest on the cash periods (averaging 1.6% a year over this span), the rule ended at $564,737. That was still below plain monthly investing.
The rule behind this question: Moving-average trading: the 200-day line, golden cross and 10-month rule
200-day rule vs. plain monthly investing, $500 a month
| Case | Put in | End balance | Total return | Annual return (IRR) | Max drawdown | Max loss vs. money in | Trades |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| QQQ 10 years, plain monthlyNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $165,815 | +176.4% | 19.3% | −35.1% | −3.2% | — |
| QQQ 10 years, 200-day ruleNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $146,319 | +143.9% | 17.0% | −23.5% | −2.2% | 35 |
| QQQ 10 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $150,702 | +151.2% | 17.6% | −23.5% | −2.2% | 35 |
| QQQ 15 years, plain monthlyNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $439,467 | +388.3% | 19.1% | −35.1% | −6.6% | — |
| QQQ 15 years, 200-day ruleNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $313,949 | +248.8% | 15.2% | −25.1% | −8.3% | 73 |
| QQQ 15 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $325,456 | +261.6% | 15.6% | −25.0% | −8.3% | 73 |
| QQQ 20 years, plain monthlyNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $983,465 | +719.6% | 18.2% | −53.5% | −43.6% | — |
| QQQ 20 years, 200-day ruleNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $542,540 | +352.1% | 13.4% | −25.1% | −8.2% | 115 |
| QQQ 20 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $564,737 | +370.6% | 13.7% | −25.0% | −7.7% | 115 |
| SPY 10 years, plain monthlyNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $133,379 | +122.3% | 15.3% | −33.7% | −13.3% | — |
| SPY 10 years, 200-day ruleNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $99,243 | +65.4% | 9.7% | −24.3% | −6.1% | 59 |
| SPY 10 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2016 to Oct 2026 | $60,000 | $101,978 | +70.0% | 10.2% | −22.6% | −5.7% | 59 |
| SPY 15 years, plain monthlyNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $295,494 | +228.3% | 14.5% | −33.7% | −4.8% | — |
| SPY 15 years, 200-day ruleNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $184,538 | +105.0% | 9.0% | −24.3% | −3.5% | 89 |
| SPY 15 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2011 to Oct 2026 | $90,000 | $190,915 | +112.1% | 9.4% | −22.6% | −3.5% | 89 |
| SPY 20 years, plain monthlyNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $557,340 | +364.4% | 13.6% | −55.3% | −44.8% | — |
| SPY 20 years, 200-day ruleNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $301,379 | +151.1% | 8.4% | −24.3% | −8.2% | 125 |
| SPY 20 years, 200-day rule with cash interestNov 2006 to Oct 2026 | $120,000 | $313,519 | +161.3% | 8.8% | −22.6% | −7.3% | 125 |
Rule: when the close is below the 200-day moving average, sell everything the next day. When it comes back above, buy again the next day. Money put in while in cash is held and invested at the next buy. Rows marked with cash interest add the 3-month Treasury bill rate to the cash; other rows leave cash at zero.
One year after buying above or below the 200-day line (QQQ, buys from 1999-12 to 2025-10)
| QQQ that day | Share of days | QQQ 1 year later, median | QQQ chance of a loss after 1 year | Next month's volatility (annual) | Daily 3x stand-in 1 year later, median | Daily 3x stand-in chance of a loss |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Above the 200-day line | 73.2% | +15.7% | 15.2% | 15.3% | +31.6% | 28.5% |
| Below the 200-day line | 26.8% | +18.9% | 36.0% | 31.8% | +39.7% | 39.1% |
The one-year windows overlap day by day, so the truly independent cases are a handful of large downturns. The daily 3x stand-in is three times QQQ's daily return minus fees and borrowing cost (US short-term rate).
How it was calculated
- $500 went in on the first trading day of every month, including the first month.
- Each buy or sell was charged 0.15% as a cost. Taxes and currency conversion costs are not included. Cash earns the 3-month Treasury bill rate only in the rows marked with cash or T-bill interest; elsewhere it earns nothing.
- Dividends were reinvested at the price on each ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.
- Annual return (IRR) is the average yearly return that accounts for when each deposit went in. Max loss vs. money in is the largest gap by which the balance fell below the total put in up to that day.
- The as-of date is the last trading day of last month (October 30, 2026). The numbers are recomputed at the start of each month.
- Buy and sell decisions use the close, and trades fill at the next trading day's open. See the backtest spec
Try it yourself
You can change the ticker, period and monthly amount and calculate the same way. No sign-in needed.
In the app, the Buy and hold row is the QQQ result on this page. The Custom rules row (moving average 2/200, holding only above the 200-day line) is calculated alongside for comparison.
This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.
Common questions
How often did it trade?
115 times over 20 years for QQQ. Trades cluster in periods when the price moves back and forth around the 200-day line.
In how many cases did the drawdown get smaller?
6 of the 6 cases calculated.
Does interest on the cash change the result?
Somewhat, but the order did not change. Even with 3-month Treasury bill interest, plain monthly investing ended higher in all 6 cases. For QQQ over 20 years it ended at $564,737, against $542,540 without interest and $983,465 for plain monthly investing.
Is this the same as the "200-day line strategy" people talk about?
It is the simplest version of it. Korean investors often apply a 200-day line rule to TQQQ with extra conditions. This calculation only looks at the 200-day line of QQQ and SPY themselves.
Isn't below the 200-day line a chance to buy cheap?
The median one-year QQQ return after buying below the 200-day line was +18.9%, higher than after buying above it (+15.7%); cheap prices often led to rebounds. But the outcomes spread out: the chance of a loss after a year rose from 15.2% to 36.0%, and next month's volatility from 15.3% to 31.8% a year. With the daily 3x stand-in, the one-year median was also higher below the line (+39.7%) than above it (+31.6%), and the chance of a loss rose from 28.5% to 39.1%. Buys on either side fell as far as −99.2% within a year when a decline kept going, so the big losses of a 3x product came less from when it was bought than from holding it through a long decline. The 200-day rule is not a rule against buying cheap; it is a selling rule that steps aside once the trend breaks and a decline continues, cutting off those losses at the cost of missing part of the rebounds.
Would the results change with an amount other than $500 a month?
In this QQQ calculation, the returns stay almost the same and only the amounts scale. Only the basket method, which buys whole shares, differs a little.
Are dividends included?
Yes. This QQQ calculation reinvests each dividend at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.
Would the result be the same when investing in a currency other than dollars?
No. This QQQ calculation is in US dollars. Exchange rate changes and the fee and tax differences of locally listed ETFs are not included.
Articles and questions on the same topic
Drawdowns and investor psychology
- Strategy articles: Investor psychology: loss aversion, the disposition effect and herd behavior, The math of loss and recovery: a halving needs a doubling
- Backtest questions: QQQ, QLD, TQQQ and SOXL at the 200-day, 50-week, 120-week and 200-week moving averages: what happened after each touch?, Doubling monthly contributions when the market is 20% below its high: did it beat the same amount every month?, Stopping or continuing monthly investing during a crash: how different were the results?
- Investor profiles: Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy (John Templeton), Contrarian Low-P/E Strategy (David Dreman)
Asset allocation and rebalancing
- Strategy articles: Asset allocation: cash 30, stocks 70, bonds and rebalancing, All Weather and the Permanent Portfolio: four-season allocations tested with ETFs
- Backtest questions: HFEA (55% UPRO, 45% TMF, rebalanced quarterly): did it still beat SPY after 2022?, TQQQ, QLD and QQQ cross-rebalancing: how does it compare with simply holding?, TQQQ value rebalancing (VR): did it beat buy and hold or regular investing in a backtest?
Moving averages and trend following
- Strategy articles: Moving-average trading: the 200-day line, golden cross and 10-month rule, Turtle trading: the 20-day and 55-day breakout rules, tested on ETFs
- Backtest questions: Holding TQQQ only while QQQ is above its 200-day line: did it beat buy and hold?, QLD (2x Nasdaq-100) with a 200-day line rule: how different were the drawdown and return from buy and hold?, Buying the golden cross (50-day above 200-day) and selling the death cross: did it beat holding?
- Investor profiles: Trend Breakout Strategy (Jesse Livermore), New-High Growth Momentum Strategy (William O'Neil)
Related questions
- How much less does a 70% stock, 30% cash mix fall than 100% stocks?
- What would investing in QQQ (Nasdaq-100) every month have returned?
- QQQ vs. SPY: how different were the results of investing monthly over the same period?
- When QQQ touched its 200-day, 50-week, 120-week or 200-week moving average, how low did it go and where was it 1 and 3 years later?
These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文