Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Quant Quality · Value Strategy
Quant Quality · Value Strategy
What is the Quant Quality · Value Strategy?
The Quant Quality and Value Strategy picks stocks by adding their ranks on two measures, return on capital (business quality) and earnings yield (price). It turns Joel Greenblatt's Magic Formula into rules.
Who He Is
Born in 1957 in the United States, he earned his bachelor's degree and MBA at Wharton. In 1985 he founded the hedge fund Gotham Capital and earned high returns for many years from special situations such as spin-offs, restructurings and mergers.
He has taught value investing at Columbia Business School since 1996, and wrote You Can Be a Stock Market Genius (1997) on special-situation investing.
He turned Buffett's principle of buying good companies at cheap prices into two numbers that anyone can follow: the Magic Formula of The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005).
The Two Numbers of the Magic Formula
Operating profit divided by enterprise value (market value plus net debt). It is similar to an inverted P/E, but because debt is included, companies with different capital structures can be compared. Higher means cheaper.
How much the business earns on the capital tied up in it. A business that earns 30 on 100 invested is better than one that earns 5. It is Buffett's moat approximated by a single number.
The method is fixed. Rank all stocks on each number, buy the 20 to 30 with the best combined rank, and pick again a year later.
Why It Works, and Why It Is Hard to Stick With
Greenblatt explains that the formula keeps working because it goes through years of trailing the market. Past data showed stretches of two to three weak years in a row, and most investors quit during them.
So the most important rule of this strategy is not to quit in a bad year.
Application Rules
For banks and insurers debt is a raw material, which distorts enterprise value and invested capital, and utilities have returns set by regulators.
The formula cannot catch problems in a single company, such as accounting issues or lawsuits, so spreading the money is part of the method.
The more often you look and tinker, the more emotion creeps in and the formula's edge disappears.
The Record
Greenblatt founded Gotham Capital in 1985 and managed outside investors' money until 1994. In a 2018 interview he said that over those ten years the fund earned 50% a year before fees and 30% a year after fees. It invested mainly in special situations such as spin-offs, restructurings and mergers.
In January 1995 Gotham returned all outside money (about $500 million, as reported) and from then on managed only the partners' own money. The publisher's author profile cites 40% a year for the 20 years after the founding, but no performance data has been published outside the firm, so none of these figures has been independently verified.
Spin-offs have some academic support. Cusatis, Miles and Woolridge (1993) reported that in 146 spin-offs from 1965 to 1988, the spun-off companies rose an average of 33.6% more than companies of similar size and industry over the following three years. The excess return, however, was concentrated in companies involved in takeovers, such as those later acquired.
The Magic Formula returns in the book are backtests calculated on past data, not results from managing real money. Those figures and other researchers' calculations are in the next section.
What Research Found
Magic Formula returns vary widely depending on who calculated them, over which period and on which universe of stocks.
| Study | Period | Magic Formula | Comparison |
|---|---|---|---|
| Greenblatt (2005) | 1988 to 2004 | 30.8% a year (22.9% among the 1,000 largest stocks) | S&P 500 12.4% a year |
| Greenblatt (2010) | 1988 to 2009 | 23.8% a year (19.7% among the 1,000 largest stocks) | S&P 500 9.5% a year |
| Gray, Carlisle (2012) | 1974 to 2011 | 13.9% a year | S&P 500 10.5% a year |
| Schwartz, Hanauer (2024) | 2000 to 2022, top 40 stocks | 15.8% a year | Market 7.2% a year (microcaps excluded) |
What held up: in calculations by researchers other than the author, the formula still beat the market. Schwartz and Hanauer (2024) excluded microcaps and covered 1963 to 2022: the top 10% of stocks by score earned 5.8 percentage points a year more than the bottom 10%, and the excess return adjusted for market risk (CAPM alpha) was 7.0% a year.
What weakened: the numbers are smaller than first published. Even the author's own figure fell from 30.8% to 23.8% a year once 2005 to 2009 was added. Schwartz and Hanauer wrote that the top stocks' lead over the market barely grew in the 21st century, and that they trailed the market from 1998 to 2000 and from 2018 to 2020. Their 40-stock portfolio trailed the market in 9 of the 23 years from 2000 to 2022, and its maximum drawdown of 50.6% was larger than the market's 44.1%. The role of the two numbers is also disputed. In Gray and Carlisle's calculation, earnings yield alone returned 15.95% a year, more than the formula. In Schwartz and Hanauer's decile comparison, the top 10% on earnings yield alone also returned more. In their 40-stock portfolios, however, adding return on capital helped.
This site's strategy panel scores have not been backtested, because historical financial data for past dates is not available, so only the present can be scored. The returns in these studies are not results of these scores.
Cautions
How This App Scores It
- Earnings yield (EBIT/EV) of 10% or above (largest weight)
- Return on capital (ROIC approximation) of 20% or above (largest weight)
- Positive operating profit in the last 4 quarters, financials and utilities excluded
Primary Sources
- Joel Greenblatt, The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005)
This strategy model was independently built by Confluence Zone to quantify the investment philosophy in the works above. It is not an official model created, endorsed or reviewed by Joel Greenblatt or any related institution. Last reviewed: 2026-10-02
Related terms: Earnings Yield · ROIC
See the Quant Quality · Value Strategy score in the app →
Other strategies
- Growth at a Reasonable Price Strategy Peter Lynch · Buys growth stocks priced below their growth rate (PEG < 1)
- New-High Growth Momentum Strategy William O'Neil · Buys leading stocks with fast-growing earnings at new highs
- Trend Template Strategy Mark Minervini · Only Stage 2 stocks, bought on the breakout after volatility shrinks
- Trend Breakout Strategy Jesse Livermore · Buys only after the trend is confirmed, when volume rises sharply
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文