Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Quality Value Strategy

Value · Margin of Safety

Quality Value Strategy

Warren Buffett · Warren Buffett · 1930– · United States
Buys wonderful companies at reasonable prices and holds them for the long run

What is the Quality Value Strategy?

The Quality Value Strategy buys companies with consistently high return on equity (ROE) at reasonable prices and holds them for the long run. It puts business quality ahead of a low price, unlike classic value investing, and turns Warren Buffett's published principles into rules.

Who He Is

Born in 1930 in Omaha, Nebraska. At 19 he read Graham's The Intelligent Investor, went to Columbia Business School to take his class, and worked at Graham-Newman for two years from 1954.

In 1956 he returned to Omaha and started an investment partnership, and in 1965 he took control of the textile company Berkshire Hathaway and turned it into a holding company. At first he bought merely cheap companies as his teacher did, but under the influence of his partner Charlie Munger and of Philip Fisher, he came to believe it is better to buy a wonderful company at a fair price than a fair company at a wonderful price.

The 1972 purchase of See's Candies is often cited as the turning point. He paid more than three times book value, which fails Graham's test, but the brand let the company raise prices, and over the following decades it produced many times the purchase price in cash.

His annual shareholder letters are read like textbooks, and he has pledged to give away most of his fortune. At the May 2025 annual meeting he said he would step down as CEO at the end of that year, with Greg Abel as his successor.

Core Concepts

Economic moat

High margins attract competitors. Companies that keep high margins for years anyway have defenses such as brands, switching costs, network effects or cost advantages. In the financial statements, they show up as consistently high ROE and operating margins.

Circle of competence

Stick to businesses you understand. Pass on businesses you cannot understand, however promising they look. That is why he avoided the losses of the late 1990s technology stocks even though he was criticized for not owning them.

Time is on the side of good companies

A company that keeps its ROE at 20% reinvests its earnings and compounds on its own. He said that if you are not willing to own a stock for ten years, you should not own it for ten minutes.

Differences in return on capital widen over time. The longer you hold, the more quality matters relative to price.ROE 20% firm (compounding)ROE 5% firmFirm value (concept - all earnings reinvested)Holding period →
Differences in return on capital widen over time. The longer you hold, the more quality matters relative to price.

Trading Rules

1. ROE of 15% or more

A company that earns at least 15 on every 100 of shareholders' money each year, consistently over several years, not just one.

2. Operating margin of 10% or more

Companies whose customers stay when prices go up have high margins. Thin-margin companies lose their profits easily in downturns or price wars.

3. Not reliant on debt

Good businesses run well without debt. If a high ROE comes from heavy debt, it is a risk, not a moat.

4. Cash, not just accounting profit

Some companies report profits but never build up cash. Check that free cash flow, the cash left after capital spending, is actually positive.

5. A reasonable price too

Even a wonderful company is not a good investment at too high a price, though he does not demand Graham-level bargains. This site allows a P/E of up to 25x.

The Record

From 1957 to 1968 the Buffett Partnership returned 31.6% a year for the partnership as a whole (before the general partner's share) and 25.3% a year for the limited partners, while the Dow returned 9.1% a year including dividends (January 1969 partnership letter).

The table in Berkshire Hathaway's 2025 shareholder letter (dated February 28, 2026, written by Greg Abel) shows per-share market value rising 19.7% a year over the 61 years from 1965 to 2025, against 10.5% a year for the S&P 500 with dividends. Cumulatively, that is 6,099,294% versus 46,061%. The figures for 1965 and 1966 are for years ending in September, and 1967 covers 15 months. Compounding the same table's yearly returns by decade shows the lead shrinking as the company grew.

PeriodBerkshire per-share market valueS&P 500 (with dividends)Difference
1965 to 197412.5% a year1.4% a year+11.1 pts
1975 to 198441.4% a year14.6% a year+26.8 pts
1985 to 199431.9% a year14.4% a year+17.5 pts
1995 to 200415.7% a year12.1% a year+3.6 pts
2005 to 20149.9% a year7.7% a year+2.2 pts
2015 to 202411.7% a year13.1% a year−1.4 pts
2025+10.9%+17.9%−7.0 pts

Berkshire trailed the S&P 500 in 21 of the 61 years. Its worst year was 1974, at −48.7%. In 2008 it returned −31.8%, a smaller loss than the S&P 500's −37.0%. In 1999, however, it returned −19.9% against +21.0%, a gap of 40.9 percentage points, and in 2019 and 2020 it averaged 6.6% a year, far below the S&P 500's 24.8%. Over the 16 years from 2010 to 2025 it returned 13.5% a year, below the S&P 500's 14.1%. Per-share market value is the stock price, so it reflects changes in how the market values the company as well as changes in the business.

As Berkshire grew, its lead over the S&P 500 shrank from 26.8 points a year in 1975 to 1984 to −1.4 points a year in 2015 to 2024.Lead over the S&P 500, annual return gap by decade+11.1 pts1965to 1974+26.8 pts1975to 1984+17.5 pts1985to 1994+3.6 pts1995to 2004+2.2 pts2005to 2014−1.4 pts2015to 2024
As Berkshire grew, its lead over the S&P 500 shrank from 26.8 points a year in 1975 to 1984 to −1.4 points a year in 2015 to 2024. Calculated by compounding the yearly per-share market value and S&P 500 (with dividends) returns in the 2025 shareholder letter by decade.

What Research Found

Frazzini, Kabiller, Pedersen (2018): cheap, safe, quality stocks plus leverage

From October 1976 to March 2017, Berkshire stock earned an average of 18.6% a year over Treasury bills with volatility of 23.5%. Its Sharpe ratio of 0.79 was 1.6 times the market's 0.49 and the highest among U.S. stocks traded for more than 40 years. Market, size, value and momentum factors did not explain it, but once the BAB factor for safe low-beta stocks and the QMJ factor for profitable quality stocks were added, the remaining excess return could not be statistically distinguished from zero. The authors estimated average leverage at about 1.7 times and the cost of insurance float, one of its funding sources, at 1.72% a year, about 3 percentage points below the Treasury bill rate.

Novy-Marx (2013): the excess return of profitable companies

From July 1963 to December 2010, the fifth of stocks with the highest gross profit to total assets earned 0.31% a month more than the lowest fifth. They did so even though profitable companies tended to have high price-to-book ratios, and a half-and-half mix with a value strategy had a Sharpe ratio of 0.85, 2.5 times the market's 0.34.

What is hard to copyBy the authors' calculation, applying 1.7 times leverage to the market gives an excess return of about 12.7% a year, short of Berkshire's 18.6%. Stock selection was a large part, but individuals cannot get long-term funding cheaper than Treasury bills. Novy-Marx also used gross profit because he saw profitability measures as noisier the further down the income statement they are taken, and earlier studies that sorted on earnings-based profitability found weak results. The ROE and operating margin this site uses differ from the measure in that study. As the previous section shows, Berkshire itself trailed the S&P 500 from 2010 to 2025.

This site's strategy panel scores have not been backtested, because historical financial data for past dates is not available, so only the present can be scored. The returns in these studies are not results of these scores.

Cautions

A quality stock is not a buy at any priceBuffett looks at price too. Ignoring price out of confidence in the business turns the strategy into collecting expensive quality stocks.
It can lag the market for yearsEven Berkshire fell well behind the market in the dot-com bubble and in 2019 and 2020. The results of this strategy show only over a full cycle.
Past ROE does not guarantee the futureMoats can erode, as they did for newspapers and department stores. You need to understand why the margins last, and numbers cannot do that for you.

How This App Scores It

This strategy card checks the following.
  • ROE of 15% or above (largest weight), ROA of 7% or above
  • Operating margin of 10% or above, debt ratio of 100% or below
  • Positive free cash flow, profitable in every verifiable year
  • P/E of 25x or below

Primary Sources

  • Warren Buffett, Berkshire Hathaway Shareholder Letters (1977–present, public primary source)

This strategy model was independently built by Confluence Zone to quantify the investment philosophy in the works above. It is not an official model created, endorsed or reviewed by Warren Buffett or any related institution. Last reviewed: 2026-10-02

Related terms: ROE · Operating Margin · Debt-to-Equity Ratio

See the Quality Value Strategy score in the app →

Other strategies

← Explore Investing Strategies

These explainers are educational summaries, independently written from publicly available books, records and interviews. No person or institution named here is evaluating or recommending any security. Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文