Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Margin-of-Safety Value Strategy
Margin-of-Safety Value Strategy
What is the Margin-of-Safety Value Strategy?
The Margin-of-Safety Value Strategy buys only at prices well below a company's intrinsic value, reducing the risk of loss first. It is the basic form of value investing, and turns Benjamin Graham's financial-safety and valuation criteria into rules.
Who He Was
Born in 1894 in London, he moved to New York with his family at the age of one. His father died early and he grew up in hardship. After graduating from Columbia University in 1914, he went to work on Wall Street.
He lost heavily in the 1929 crash, and from that experience set out a way to treat investing as analysis rather than instinct. His best-known books are Security Analysis (1934, with David Dodd) and The Intelligent Investor (1949).
He ran the Graham-Newman investment firm from 1936 to 1956 and taught for many years at Columbia Business School. Warren Buffett took his class and later worked at Graham-Newman. In 1948 he invested in the insurer GEICO and earned a large return.
He called something an investment only if thorough analysis protected the principal and promised a reasonable return; anything else was speculation. He died in France in 1976.
Two Core Concepts
The market is like a business partner who quotes a different price every day depending on his mood. Buy when he is gloomy and quotes low, sell when he is excited and quotes high. The price is an offer, not a verdict on value.
Intrinsic value cannot be calculated exactly, so buy cheap enough that a wrong estimate still does not lose money. Buy a stock you value at 100 for 60, and you still profit even if the estimate is 20% too high.
Criteria for the Defensive Investor
Graham left criteria that can be checked with numbers, for people without time to research stocks in depth. This site's scoring follows them.
P/E of 15x or below and P/B of 1.5x or below, and the two multiplied should not exceed 22.5 (the Graham number). If one is a little high, it still passes when the other is low enough.
A current ratio of at least 2x, and debt smaller than equity. A cheap stock with weak finances is not a margin of safety.
Profitable throughout the verifiable period, and paying dividends.
If the market value is below net current assets (current assets minus total liabilities), you are paying less than what would be left if the company were liquidated. These are very rare today, but when found they offer the clearest margin of safety.
The Record
Graham opened the Benjamin Graham Joint Account in 1926 to manage investors' money, then founded the Graham-Newman Corporation in 1936 and ran it until 1956. The figures below differ by who calculated them and how, and they are unverified because they could not be recalculated from original records.
According to Graham's memoirs, the Joint Account returned −20% in 1929, −50.5% in 1930, −16% in 1931 and −3% in 1932. Compounded over the four years, that is a loss of about 68%.
In the 2003 revised edition of The Intelligent Investor, Jason Zweig calculated Graham-Newman's return from 1936 to 1956 at 14.7% a year or more, and the stock market as a whole at 12.2% a year over the same period. Some sources give higher figures, so the results differ by method.
In his 1988 shareholder letter, Buffett wrote that while working at Graham-Newman he studied its arbitrage record for 1926 to 1956 and found unleveraged returns averaging 20% a year. That covers only trades on announced events such as mergers and liquidations, not the firm's total return.
In 1948 Graham-Newman bought about half of the insurer GEICO for $712,500, and the same year distributed the shares separately to its own shareholders. In a postscript to the 1973 edition of The Intelligent Investor, Graham wrote that the profit from this single investment exceeded the combined profit of all other operations over 20 years. The largest share of a record built on diversification and margin of safety came from one stock, and the figures above change depending on how this stock is counted.
What Research Found
The core of Graham's criteria is buying cheaply relative to asset value. These are the main studies that tested it.
| Study | Period | Criterion tested | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fama, French (1992) | 1963 to 1990 | Deciles of book-to-market | Cheapest 1.83% a month, most expensive 0.30% |
| Fama, French (2021) | 1963 to 2019 | Value stocks' return over the market | 0.42% a month in the first 28 years, 0.11% in the last 28 |
| Oppenheimer (1986) | 1970 to 1983 | Price at or below two-thirds of net current assets | 29.4% a year on average, NYSE-AMEX index 11.5% |
| Carlisle et al. (2010) | 1984 to 2008 | Same criterion | 2.55% a month, NYSE-AMEX index 0.85% a month |
What held up: in the United States, stocks that were cheap relative to book value earned more than expensive ones over long periods, and in the Fama and French (1992) sample beta did not explain the gap. Stocks priced below net current assets (net-nets) also beat the index by a wide margin in both studies.
What did not: the value premium shrank after 1991, and monthly swings are too large to tell statistically whether it truly declined. Calculated from Kenneth French's data, the value-minus-growth factor (HML) returned −5.7% a year over the 14 years from 2007 to 2020. Net-nets are mostly small, thinly traded stocks. In the Carlisle et al. (2010) sample, an average of 54 stocks a year qualified, 76% of them on Nasdaq. Excluding stocks under $5 cut the monthly return to 1.6%. These studies also tested book value and net current asset criteria, not the P/E × P/B of 22.5 rule this site uses.
This site's strategy panel scores have not been backtested, because historical financial data for past dates is not available, so only the present can be scored. The returns in these studies are not results of these scores.
Cautions
How This App Scores It
- P/E x P/B of 22.5 or below (largest weight)
- P/E of 15x or below, P/B of 1.5x or below
- Current ratio of 2x or above, debt ratio of 100% or below
- Profitable in every verifiable year, dividends paid, below net current assets (bonus)
Primary Sources
- Benjamin Graham, The Intelligent Investor (1949; rev. eds.)
- Benjamin Graham & David Dodd, Security Analysis (1934)
This strategy model was independently built by Confluence Zone to quantify the investment philosophy in the works above. It is not an official model created, endorsed or reviewed by Benjamin Graham or any related institution. Last reviewed: 2026-10-02
Related terms: PER · PBR · Debt-to-Equity Ratio · Current Ratio
See the Margin-of-Safety Value Strategy score in the app →
Other strategies
- Quality Value Strategy Warren Buffett · Buys wonderful companies at reasonable prices and holds them for the long run
- Absolute-Return Margin of Safety Strategy Seth Klarman · Puts not losing first, and buys below liquidation value
- Contrarian Bargain-Buying Strategy John Templeton · Buys when everyone gives up, but only companies that will survive
- Contrarian Low-P/E Strategy David Dreman · Buys the cheap stocks the market ignores, by the rules
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文