Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › Leveraged ETF rules

HFEA (55% UPRO, 45% TMF, rebalanced quarterly): did it still beat SPY after 2022?

HFEA (55% UPRO, 45% TMF, reset quarterly) since 2009 vs. SPY, UPRO alone and 60/40, with 2022, when stocks and Treasuries fell together.

Summary

$10,000 split 55% UPRO and 45% TMF in July 2009 and reset every quarter was worth $367,740 at the as-of date, 23.1% a year. The same money in SPY reached $110,720 (14.9% a year), and in UPRO alone $1,235,026.

2022 was the turning point. SPY returned −18.2% and TMF −72.6% as stocks and long Treasuries fell together, and HFEA returned −63.8%. HFEA fell 70.6% from its December 2021 high to October 2023. At the as-of date it was still 34.7% below that high.

Over the last five years HFEA returned −6.7% a year and SPY 11.9%. HFEA beat SPY in 70% of the 149 five-year windows.

The rule behind this question: All Weather and the Permanent Portfolio: four-season allocations tested with ETFs

$10,000 once, full period

CaseEnd balanceTotal returnAnnual returnMax drawdown2022
HFEA: UPRO 55%, TMF 45%, quarterlyJul 2009 to Oct 2026$367,740+3,577.4%23.1%−70.6%−63.8%
Same mix, monthly$248,110+2,381.1%20.4%−70.2%−62.9%
Same mix, yearly$196,438+1,864.4%18.7%−69.5%−63.8%
UPRO 40%, TMF 60%, quarterly$144,488+1,344.9%16.7%−75.4%−66.2%
Hold UPRO$1,235,026+12,250.3%32.0%−76.8%−56.8%
Hold TMF$4,313−56.9%−4.7%−94.3%−72.6%
Hold SPY$110,720+1,007.2%14.9%−33.7%−18.2%
SPY 60%, IEF 40%, quarterly$54,242+442.4%10.2%−21.3%−16.7%

Last 10 and 5 years

CaseEnd balanceTotal returnAnnual returnMax drawdown
10 years, HFEA: UPRO 55%, TMF 45%, quarterlyNov 2016 to Oct 2026$36,746+267.5%13.9%−70.6%
10 years, Hold UPRONov 2016 to Oct 2026$127,473+1,174.7%29.0%−76.8%
10 years, Hold SPYNov 2016 to Oct 2026$41,435+314.3%15.3%−33.7%
10 years, SPY 60%, IEF 40%, quarterlyNov 2016 to Oct 2026$25,247+152.5%9.7%−21.3%
5 years, HFEA: UPRO 55%, TMF 45%, quarterlyNov 2021 to Oct 2026$7,059−29.4%−6.7%−70.7%
5 years, Hold UPRONov 2021 to Oct 2026$20,995+109.9%16.0%−63.9%
5 years, Hold SPYNov 2021 to Oct 2026$17,501+75.0%11.9%−24.5%
5 years, SPY 60%, IEF 40%, quarterlyNov 2021 to Oct 2026$13,784+37.8%6.6%−21.3%

Calendar-year returns, distributions reinvested

YearHFEAUPROTMFSPYSPY 60%, IEF 40%
2010+46.5%+36.3%+16.1%+15.1%+13.6%
2011+63.2%−11.9%+109.2%+1.9%+8.3%
2012+31.3%+46.8%+0.6%+16.0%+11.2%
2013+28.8%+118.5%−39.0%+32.3%+15.7%
2014+62.8%+38.0%+97.3%+13.5%+11.7%
2015−3.9%−5.2%−13.7%+1.2%+1.6%
2016+19.3%+30.8%−2.5%+12.0%+7.6%
2017+48.8%+71.4%+22.7%+21.7%+13.8%
2018−13.5%−25.1%−11.0%−4.6%−1.8%
2019+75.7%+102.3%+34.8%+31.2%+21.8%
2020+79.1%+10.1%+39.0%+18.3%+17.7%
2021+38.9%+98.6%−19.8%+28.7%+15.2%
2022−63.8%−56.8%−72.6%−18.2%−16.7%
2023+28.3%+68.5%−13.0%+26.2%+16.8%
2024+13.1%+63.6%−35.9%+24.9%+14.3%
2025+18.4%+31.9%−2.9%+17.7%+14.0%

Every five-year window, HFEA vs. SPY

Five-year windowsHFEA ahead of SPYHFEA ended with a lossMedian HFEA annual returnMedian SPY annual returnWorst HFEA start
14970%11%23.4%13.9%−6.7%Nov 2021
$10,000 at the start: HFEA vs. UPRO, SPY and 60/40 (month-end, log scale)Month-end balance of $10,000, Jul 2009 to Oct 2026. In the last month HFEA was at $367,740, UPRO $1,235,026, SPY $110,720 and SPY 60%, IEF 40% $54,242.$10k$25k$50k$100k$250k$500k$1MUPROHFEASPYSPY 60%201020122014201620182020202220242026
Month-end balance of $10,000, Jul 2009 to Oct 2026. In the last month HFEA was at $367,740, UPRO $1,235,026, SPY $110,720 and SPY 60%, IEF 40% $54,242.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

Rules that keep a mix of two ETFs, like HFEA, are not in the backtest tool yet. Holding UPRO over the same period can be calculated there.

Calculate with these settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

Where did HFEA come from?

It started with the 2019 Bogleheads forum thread "HEDGEFUNDIE's excellent adventure" and spread on Reddit's leveraged ETF boards. The idea is to mix 3× stocks with 3× long-term Treasuries so that bonds cushion falls in stocks. The original author's backtest figures are not quoted on this page.

How often did stocks and Treasuries fall in the same year?

From 2010 to 2025, UPRO and TMF both fell in 2015, 2018 and 2022. HFEA returned −3.9% in 2015, −13.5% in 2018 and −63.8% in 2022.

How much did the rebalancing schedule matter?

With the same 55/45 mix, quarterly rebalancing returned 23.1% a year, monthly 20.4% and yearly 18.7%. Max drawdowns were −70.6%, −70.2% and −69.5%, almost the same. No schedule avoided the 2022 fall.

Why did TMF fall so far?

TMF targets three times the daily return of US Treasuries over 20 years. When rates rise, long bond prices fall, and leverage, volatility and financing costs magnify the fall. TMF fell 94.3% from its March 2020 high to October 2026.

Was it better than holding UPRO alone?

Over the whole period, UPRO alone ended higher (32.0% a year vs. 23.1% for HFEA). Max drawdowns were −76.8% for UPRO and −70.6% for HFEA. The deepest fall bottomed in March 2020 for UPRO and in October 2023 for HFEA.

Are dividends included?

Yes. UPRO, TMF, SPY and IEF all reinvest each distribution at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on distributions are not deducted.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Leveraged ETFs (TQQQ, QLD, SOXL)

Asset allocation and rebalancing

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文