Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Leveraged ETF strategies
Value rebalancing (VR): buy and sell to follow a target value V
A Korean community rule: target V rises every two weeks and TQQQ trades back to V only beyond 15% away. The formula, our assumptions, results since 2010.
In one line
A target line V for the TQQQ value rises by formula, and the rule trades only when the value leaves the band. With G at 10 over the last 10 years, the average stock share was 89%, so the result (41.4% a year, max drawdown −79.9%) stayed close to holding TQQQ (40.9% a year, −81.7%).
Backtest results for this strategy: TQQQ value rebalancing (VR): did it beat buy and hold or regular investing in a backtest?
Article
Monthly investing in TQQQ puts in the same amount whether the price rises or falls. Value averaging works the other way: it first sets what the account should be worth, then buys more when it falls short and sells when it runs over. Value rebalancing (VR), by the Korean blogger Laoer, adapts that idea to TQQQ. A target line V rises by formula every two weeks, and the holding is brought back to V only when its value moves outside a band 15% above or below V.
This article writes the formula from the public VR 5.0 summaries as the rule this site calculates, and sets out the assumptions added where the original is silent along with TQQQ results since 2010.
Formula and rules
- V: the target line the TQQQ value follows. The first V is the value of the TQQQ bought on day one.
- Pool: the cash held to buy TQQQ.
- G: sets how fast V rises. A larger G makes V rise more slowly. The summaries start at 10 for the lump-sum and monthly versions and 20 for the withdrawal version.
- Updating V: every two weeks, new V = previous V + pool ÷ G + contribution. The withdrawal version subtracts the withdrawal.
- Band: 85% to 115% of V. Below the band it buys up to V; above it, it sells down to V. Inside the band it does nothing.
- Pool limit: the money spent on buying in one cycle is capped at 50% of the pool for the lump-sum version, 75% of the pool after the contribution for the monthly version, and 25% for the withdrawal version.
This site's assumptions
The original builds two weeks of buy and sell orders in advance and does not fix how to split the starting money between stock and pool. This calculation assumes:
- 87% (1 ÷ 1.15) of the starting money buys TQQQ and the rest is the pool. This is the starting split the summaries derive from an average pool-to-V ratio of 0.15.
- A cycle is 10 trading days. Within a cycle the value is checked at every close, and it buys or sells back to V at the close on days it leaves the band.
- G is fixed at 10. The original suggests raising G every year to flatten V.
- The pool earns no interest, share counts are fractional, and each trade is charged 0.15%.
This site's results (as of Sep 2026)
We put $10,000 into TQQQ and calculated the 10 years from October 2016. Value rebalancing ended at $317,690, 41.4% a year, with a max drawdown of −79.9%. Holding TQQQ ended at $307,012 (40.9% a year, −81.7%). With an average stock share of 89%, the result stayed close to buy and hold.
Raising G to 20 lowered the average stock share to 82% and returned 39.1% a year. In the monthly version with $250 added every two weeks (pool limit 75%), $72,750 put in became $812,514, against $773,493 for simply buying TQQQ on the same days. Of 4,173 trading days since March 2010, there were 688 days when the value was below the band but the cycle's limit had been used up.
The monthly recalculated figures, the table by setting and every three-year window are in the TQQQ value rebalancing backtest. The backtest tool reruns the same rule with another ticker, period, G or band. Results on SOXL are in the SOXL question.
How it differs from related rules
In value rebalancing one target line, V, decides both when to buy and when to sell. Even among TQQQ rules, the stock share is very different from rules driven by the calendar or by stages of a decline.
| Rule | When it buys | When it sells | 10-year annual return | Max drawdown |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Value rebalancing (VR) | Stock value below 85% of V | Stock value above 115% of V | 41.4% | −79.9% |
| Infinite buying | One unit a day at or below the average cost (up to +5% in the first half) | Everything at the average cost +10% | 22.2% | −49.6% |
| QQQ 200-day rule | TQQQ while QQQ closes above its 200-day line | All to cash below the line | 44.3% | −57.9% |
| Cross-rebalancing | TQQQ at each stage of a QQQ decline | To QLD at the old high, to QQQ when overheated | 30.1% | −55.0% |
| Basket method | Fill slots to the target each month | Once full, the excess of one slot a month | Monthly rule, calculated separately | Calculated separately |
| Hold TQQQ | Once on day one | Never | 40.9% | −81.7% |
$10,000 at the start, October 2016 to September 2026, calculated with this site's engine. Cross-rebalancing is the default TQQQ, QLD and QQQ model in the backtest tool. The basket method adds money every month, so its results are in the basket method backtest.
Related concepts and search terms
- Value averaging: the method described by Michael Edleson, which sets a target value for each period and puts in more when short and less, or sells, when over. V is that target line.
- Rebalancing bands: rules that act only when a holding drifts a set distance from its target. The ±15% band is one.
- The basket method: the second rule the same author placed beside VR. Splitting a target amount into slots is what it shares with VR (Basket method).
Search terms: value rebalancing, VR, Laoer, TQQQ VR, value averaging, rebalancing bands.
Drawbacks and risks
- With a small G, V rises quickly and the stock share stays high, so it takes nearly the full TQQQ drawdown. The max drawdown in this calculation was −79.9%.
- In large declines the pool limit stops it from buying back to V. Buying past the limit empties the pool and leaves nothing for the next decline.
- V and the order table have to be recalculated every two weeks. One mistake throws off every V after it.
- Every sale realizes a capital gain and is taxed. This calculation leaves taxes out.
Operator's assessment
In numbers, value rebalancing with G at 10 is a rule that holds TQQQ almost as it is and occasionally trims and refills it. Over the last 10 years both its return and its drawdown were within 2 points of buy and hold, and across three-year windows it ended higher than holding in 33% of them while its drawdown was slightly smaller in all of them. Cutting the drawdown a lot would take a larger G or a lower starting stock share, which earns less in rallies. The operator thinks the numbers fit better if the rule's value is seen in fixing in advance when and how much to trade, rather than in its return.
What this article does not cover
This article does not recommend any ETF, G value or band width. The figures are past results from this site's engine (dividends reinvested, 0.15% cost per trade, no interest on the pool, checks at the close, fractional shares). The original uses advance orders and raises G each year, so results can differ, and taxes and currency are for each reader to check. Everything here is reference information based on past, public data and is not investment advice.
Articles and questions on the same topic
Leveraged ETFs (TQQQ, QLD, SOXL)
- Strategy articles: Leveraged ETFs at a glance: monthly investing and five rules
- Backtest questions: TQQQ infinite buying method: did it beat buy and hold in a backtest?, Holding TQQQ only while QQQ is above its 200-day line: did it beat buy and hold?, QLD (2x Nasdaq-100) with a 200-day line rule: how different were the drawdown and return from buy and hold?
Asset allocation and rebalancing
- Strategy articles: Plan before entry: reason, exit condition, entry price and stop, All Weather and the Permanent Portfolio: four-season allocations tested with ETFs
- Backtest questions: How much less does a 70% stock, 30% cash mix fall than 100% stocks?, HFEA (55% UPRO, 45% TMF, rebalanced quarterly): did it still beat SPY after 2022?, TQQQ, QLD and QQQ cross-rebalancing: how does it compare with simply holding?
Related
Value rebalancing backtest results · Infinite buying · Basket method · Leverage cross-rebalancing · Asset allocation · The math of loss and recovery
Basics and trading strategies
← Infinite buying: buy in 40 steps, sell at 10% above the average cost · Contents · Grid trading: buy at each line down, sell one line up →
See these metrics on a real stock →
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文