Open the analyzer →

Home › Explore Investing Strategies › Questions and answers › How to invest and taxes

Doubling monthly contributions when the market is 20% below its high: did it beat the same amount every month?

$500 a month into QQQ, SPY and TQQQ, doubled in months 10, 20 or 30% below the high, across every 10-year window, plus saving the extra money first.

Summary

Putting $500 a month into QQQ for 10 years from November 2016, and $1,000 in months when QQQ was more than 20% below its high, returned 19.6% a year (IRR). That was +0.25 pp above 19.3% for $500 every month. It doubled in 13 months and put in $6,500 more.

Shifting the 10-year window a month at a time, the doubling rule had the higher annual return in 55% of QQQ windows, 100% of SPY windows and 93% of TQQQ windows, with median gaps of +0.01 pp for QQQ, +0.42 pp for SPY and +0.76 pp for TQQQ.

It looks different when the extra money has to be saved first. Keeping $100 of each $500 in cash and adding it in months below −20% beat putting the full $500 in every month in 7% of QQQ windows, 50% of SPY windows and 0% of TQQQ windows.

The rule behind this question: Averaging down and pyramiding: which way to add

Annual return (IRR): the same amount every month vs. doubling at −20%

Case$500 a monthDouble at −20%GapDoubled monthsExtra moneySame money, saved ahead
QQQ, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 202619.3%19.6%+0.25 pp13$6,50018.2%
QQQ, 20 yearsNov 2006 to Oct 202618.2%18.1%−0.06 pp106$53,00018.0%
SPY, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 202615.3%15.4%+0.10 pp3$1,50013.8%
SPY, 20 yearsNov 2006 to Oct 202613.6%13.8%+0.24 pp33$16,50013.2%
TQQQ, 10 yearsNov 2016 to Oct 202633.5%34.4%+0.83 pp52$26,00033.2%

Every 10-year window: gap in annual return vs. $500 a month

ETF and triggerWindowsDoubling aheadMedian gapRange of gapsSaving aheadMedian gap, saving
QQQ −10%21254%0.00 pp−0.43 pp to +0.44 pp12%−0.04 pp
QQQ −20%21255%+0.01 pp−0.52 pp to +0.49 pp7%−0.18 pp
QQQ −30%21256%+0.04 pp−0.44 pp to +0.72 pp9%−0.27 pp
SPY −10%27594%+0.24 pp−0.23 pp to +0.95 pp30%−0.23 pp
SPY −20%275100%+0.42 pp+0.01 pp to +1.06 pp50%−0.01 pp
SPY −30%27573%+0.55 pp0.00 pp to +1.03 pp54%+0.15 pp
TQQQ −10%81100%+0.73 pp+0.01 pp to +1.04 pp22%−0.13 pp
TQQQ −20%8193%+0.76 pp−0.33 pp to +1.12 pp0%−0.29 pp
TQQQ −30%8188%+0.40 pp−0.45 pp to +1.16 pp0%−1.77 pp
10 years of monthly investing: doubling at −20% minus the same amount every month (by start month)Annual return of $500 a month for 10 years with $1,000 in months 20% or more below the high, minus the annual return of $500 every month. QQQ: higher in 55% of 212 windows. SPY: higher in 100% of 275 windows.−1%−0%0%+0%+1%+2%QQQSPY199620002004200820122016
Annual return of $500 a month for 10 years with $1,000 in months 20% or more below the high, minus the annual return of $500 every month. QQQ: higher in 55% of 212 windows. SPY: higher in 100% of 275 windows.

How it was calculated

Try it yourself

The doubling rule is not in the backtest tool yet. The plain $500 a month it is compared with can be calculated there with the same settings.

Calculate with these settings

This page runs to its base date, and the button opens the app with the same dates. To see the latest trading day, change the period in the app.

Common questions

The money put in differs. How is it compared?

By annual return (IRR). IRR accounts for the date and size of each deposit, so what remains in the result is when the money went in, not how much more went in. In the same 10 years of QQQ, $500 a month turned $60,000 into $165,815, and the doubling rule turned $66,500 into $181,323.

How is the drop from the high measured?

The close on the trading day before each deposit is compared with the highest close up to then, using split-adjusted prices without dividends, as on a chart. QQQ and SPY highs go back to their 1990s launches, TQQQ's to 2010.

What happens when a drawdown lasts a long time?

The doubled months keep coming. QQQ stayed more than 20% below its high for 166 months in a row, from October 2000 to July 2014. The rule doubled every one of those months, and the money for it had to keep coming.

What is the trigger for TQQQ?

TQQQ's own drop from its high. TQQQ falls far, so 52 of its 120 months over 10 years were 20% or more below the high. Using QQQ's drop instead would double far fewer months.

Is this the same as averaging down?

No. Averaging down buys more of a holding that is at a loss to lower the average cost. This rule looks at the price's drop from its high, not at your own gain or loss, so it can double even while the account is in profit.

Isn't this the opposite of the 200-day rule?

Yes. Doubling on drops buys more as prices fall, while the 200-day rule steps aside when the trend breaks. The median one-year QQQ return after buying below the 200-day line was +18.9%, higher than after buying above it (+15.7%); cheap prices often led to rebounds. But the outcomes spread out: the chance of a loss after a year rose from 15.2% to 36.0%, and next month's volatility from 15.3% to 31.8% a year. For 1x monthly investing, continuing to buy below the line usually did better (see the 200-day rule DCA question). With the daily 3x stand-in, the one-year median was also higher below the line (+39.7%) than above it (+31.6%), and the chance of a loss rose from 28.5% to 39.1%. Buys on either side fell as far as −99.2% within a year when a decline kept going, so the big losses of a 3x product came less from when it was bought than from holding it through a long decline. The 200-day rule is not a rule against buying cheap; it is a selling rule that steps aside once the trend breaks and a decline continues, cutting off those losses at the cost of missing part of the rebounds.

Are dividends included?

Yes. This QQQ, SPY and TQQQ doubling on drops calculation reinvests each dividend at the price on its ex-dividend date. Taxes on dividends are not deducted.

Would the result be the same when investing in a currency other than dollars?

No. This QQQ, SPY and TQQQ doubling on drops calculation is in US dollars. Exchange rate changes and the fee and tax differences of locally listed ETFs are not included.

Articles and questions on the same topic

Monthly investing and lump sums

Drawdowns and investor psychology

Related questions

These results are calculated from past prices. They do not guarantee future returns and do not recommend any product.

Confluence Zone is an analysis tool for information and research; it is not investment advice, a solicitation, or a trading instruction. Investment decisions and their outcomes are your own responsibility.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文