Swaps to the formula's picks every year, without emotion
Fixed rulesFinancials and valueSpread wide
I am a
Joel Greenblatt type
#Magic formulaThe formula keeper
Repeats a formula for buying good companies cheaply, without emotion.
- Ranks by return on capital and earnings yield
- Rebalances mechanically every year
- Sticks with the formula through dry spells
Closest styles in your answers
The share of your answer points that went to each style.
Style profile
Where this style stands at five crossroads of investing.
How this investor works
It reduces buying good companies cheaply to two numbers: how much the business earns on the capital it uses (return on capital) and how large its earnings are relative to its price (earnings yield). Stocks are ranked on each, the ranks are added, and buying starts from the top.
It buys 20 to 30 names, holds them for a year, then re-ranks and replaces them. Less judgement and strict rule-keeping are the whole point.
It knows the formula can trail the market for years. Greenblatt explained that it keeps working precisely because few people can sit through those years.
Joel Greenblatt: Who He Is
Born in 1957 in the United States, he earned his bachelor's degree and MBA at Wharton. In 1985 he founded the hedge fund Gotham Capital and earned high returns for many years from special situations such as spin-offs, restructurings and mergers.
He has taught value investing at Columbia Business School since 1996, and wrote You Can Be a Stock Market Genius (1997) on special-situation investing.
He turned Buffett's principle of buying good companies at cheap prices into two numbers that anyone can follow: the Magic Formula of The Little Book That Beats the Market (2005).
Show the track record
Greenblatt founded Gotham Capital in 1985 and managed outside investors' money until 1994. In a 2018 interview he said that over those ten years the fund earned 50% a year before fees and 30% a year after fees. It invested mainly in special situations such as spin-offs, restructurings and mergers.
In January 1995 Gotham returned all outside money (about $500 million, as reported) and from then on managed only the partners' own money. The publisher's author profile cites 40% a year for the 20 years after the founding, but no performance data has been published outside the firm, so none of these figures has been independently verified.
Spin-offs have some academic support. Cusatis, Miles and Woolridge (1993) reported that in 146 spin-offs from 1965 to 1988, the spun-off companies rose an average of 33.6% more than companies of similar size and industry over the following three years. The excess return, however, was concentrated in companies involved in takeovers, such as those later acquired.
The Magic Formula returns in the book are backtests calculated on past data, not results from managing real money. Those figures and other researchers' calculations are in the next section.
Strengths and pitfalls
Strengths
- It repeats the same rule without emotion
- It weighs quality and price together
- It takes little time
Common pitfalls
- A run of bad years makes quitting tempting
- It cannot see business changes behind the numbers
- Some sectors, like financials, do not fit the formula
Shines in
Periods when value is rerated
Struggles in
Markets carried by a few mega-cap growth stocks
How it relates to other styles
Explore this style
The analysis screen scores one stock against all ten legends at once. The same stock splits their verdicts. See a stock through all ten legends →
Other styles
- Mark Minervini typeStage two trend hunter
- William O'Neil typeNew high leader chaser
- Jesse Livermore typeThe big move speculator
- Warren Buffett typeThe moat-seeking owner
- Peter Lynch typeThe everyday growth detective
- Benjamin Graham typeThe margin of safety calculator
- Seth Klarman typeThe patient cash hunter
- John Templeton typeThe buyer at maximum pessimism
- David Dreman typeThe overreaction exploiter
- Joel Greenblatt typeThe formula keeper
- 200-day guardianThe trend filter believer
- Steady accumulatorThe buyer of time
A style quiz for fun. It is not a suitability assessment or a product recommendation.
About & methodology · Explore Investing Strategies · Glossary · Questions and answers · Rule status · Sample analysis · Pricing · Terms · Investment disclosure · Privacy policy · Open the analyzer · 한국어 · 日本語 · 繁體中文 · 简体中文